All-Time Panthers Team:

[nosuchthingasapanther]

If you mean Davis as a Panther. Davis in his prime? Arguably...

That's not taking a thing away from Williams. I love me some DeAngelo...

thank you.

williams has yet to do what davis has done in his prime.

[Panthro]

thank you.

williams has yet to do what davis has done in his prime.

For the Panthers he has...

[Old School80]

There is no right or wrong answer, is just who you think. I probably should've taken Willams since I am wearing his jersey right now!

[The Link]

thank you.

williams has yet to do what davis has done in his prime.

Williams did more already.

Williams had more yards and touchdowns last year than Davis ever did in the span of a single season.

Again, Williams>Davis.

http://www.nfl.com/players/profile?id=WIL221323

http://www.nfl.com/players/stephendavis/profile?id=DAV751941

[KillerKat]

Jake is clearly the best QB we have ever had.

Beuerlein beats him in every QB category.

Beuerlein >>> Delhomme

[The Link]

I want a Williams jersey now, lol.

[frash.exe]

It's weird. I don't know if I believe in just inserting the best talent gives you the best team you can have (ask Redskin fans). A lot of what makes a team great is chemistry. We put these "best" players in their prime on one team, hey, they might make some plays, but they might also not work together very well. Maybe the all time Panthers team was the one that made the Superbowl in 2003. They reached heights of which the Panthers never saw before, or since.

[mantal]

It's weird. I don't know if I believe in just inserting the best talent gives you the best team you can have (ask Redskin fans). A lot of what makes a team great is chemistry. We put these "best" players in their prime on one team, hey, they might make some plays, but they might also not work together very well. Maybe the all time Panthers team was the one that made the Superbowl in 2003. They reached heights of which the Panthers never saw before, or since.

Well that was pretty much perfectly stated...

[nosuchthingasapanther]

Williams did more already.

Williams had more yards and touchdowns last year than Davis ever did in the span of a single season.

Again, Williams>Davis.

http://www.nfl.com/players/profile?id=WIL221323

http://www.nfl.com/players/stephendavis/profile?id=DAV751941

until williams produces consistent numbers in multiple seasons...

davis > williams.

in his prime 99-2003, davis had 1 season of 1300+ yards and 3 1400+ yards.

by your logic (basing everything on a single season)..

stewart > williams seeing as how stewart set franchise records his rookie season while williams did nothing.

and he did it playing second fiddle to a much better starter (williams) than williams (foster), didn't start a single game, almost no offseason workout, coming off surgery, and playing banged up for 3-4 games.

[Panthro]

It's weird. I don't know if I believe in just inserting the best talent gives you the best team you can have (ask Redskin fans). A lot of what makes a team great is chemistry. We put these "best" players in their prime on one team, hey, they might make some plays, but they might also not work together very well. Maybe the all time Panthers team was the one that made the Superbowl in 2003. They reached heights of which the Panthers never saw before, or since.

I'd take a better back 4 just for that game

[frash.exe]

I'd take a better back 4 just for that game

hey i said it was the best overall team we'd ever fielded. I didn't say it was flawless.:hand:

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

Head Coach: Dom Capers

QB- Steve Beuerlein

RB- DeAngelo Williams

FB- Brad Hoover

TE- Wesley Walls

WR- Steve Smith

WR- Muhsin Muhammad

T- Jordan Gross

T- Todd Steussie

G- Mike Whale

G- Nate Newton

C- Jeff Mitchell

DE- Julius Peppers

DT- Brenston Buckner

DT- Kris Jenkins

DE- Mike Rucker

LB- Sam Mills

LB- Lamar Lathon

LB- Kevin Greene

CB- Chris Gamble

CB- Eric Davis

S- Mike Minter

S- Chad Cota

P- Todd Sauerbrun

K- John Kasay

KS- Rhys Lloyd

KR/PR-Michael Bates

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

until williams produces consistent numbers in multiple seasons...

davis > williams.

in his prime 99-2003, davis had 1 season of 1300+ yards and 3 1400+ yards.

by your logic (basing everything on a single season)..

stewart > williams seeing as how stewart set franchise records his rookie season while williams did nothing.

and he did it playing second fiddle to a much better starter (williams) than williams (foster), didn't start a single game, almost no offseason workout, coming off surgery, and playing banged up for 3-4 games.

You know there is a thing on the Panthers website called all time leaders you may wanna check it out. Williams has already decimated everyones records except Fosters in yards and attempts only because Foster had played for the Panthers longer than Williams has. WILLIAMS>>>>>>>>>>>>davis. I loved davis don't get me wrong but Williams is a helluva lot better player than davis was.

[The Link]

until williams produces consistent numbers in multiple seasons...

davis > williams.

in his prime 99-2003, davis had 1 season of 1300+ yards and 3 1400+ yards.

by your logic (basing everything on a single season)..

stewart > williams seeing as how stewart set franchise records his rookie season while williams did nothing.

and he did it playing second fiddle to a much better starter (williams) than williams (foster), didn't start a single game, almost no offseason workout, coming off surgery, and playing banged up for 3-4 games.

Williams is better now than Davis was, IMO, and he (hopefully) will continue to be.

In the end this is all just opinions.