Cam up for Rookie of the Week again...

[TheRealDeal]

I'm taking AP. A game changer that gets 25-30 touches a game vs a game changer who gets it 6 times a game?

Ninja please

[ItsNotGonnaBeAlright]

When your play warrants you being with 2 #1 overalls and you were picked for simply #5, it's a steal if I ever saw one.

We are looking at possibly the greatest returner the game has ever seen AND the greatest corner the game has ever seen. Can you really put a price on that? Dominating two phases of the game?

Look, Cam's good but I wouldn't call him the best returner I've ever seen. He has been a hell of a playmaker on defense though.

[ed bell]

The shelf-life aspect of Calvin Johnson over AP has merit since all-time WR's can go to 35+ and still add something to an offense, but I'm not a fan of the "it's easy to find another RB" line of thinking. I don't buy it.

I think back to Barry Sanders laboring away in Detroit and remaining relevant to the day he hung up the cleats. It seems like the game has given up on having that type player. Just the ever changing landscape of Pro-Football I guess.

[Floppin]

I'm taking AP. A game changer that gets 25-30 touches a game vs a game changer who gets it 6 times a game?

Ninja please

Touches matter how?

AP:

997total yards, 12 total TD, 4.7 yards per touch

CJ:

1023total yards, 12 total TD, 16.2 yards per touch

If anything you could argue that Megatron is a more productive player.

[King Taharqa]

U are so funny. U find fault with everything Cam does and use it as grounds not to support while u get excited over Peterson and ignore all of his mistakes and weaknesses.

TRD doesnt really like PP. He is a white racist, and white racists are very sensitive and insecure about the glory black quarterbacks receive from non racist whites. Just know any success or acclaim Cameron receives TRD takes it personal and feels the need to reaffirm his heritage by bashing Cam. Its the "i can only love myself if i hate everuone else" culture he was raised in. Hes spent a year slighting Cam on this board because he wants to fit in desperately. TRDs act is a constant reminder of the persistent illogical racial bias that once was very prevelant in our fanbase. There isnt a white QB out there TRD hasnt claimed or portrayed as being better than our QB. And keep in mind he needs the safety and anonymity of the net to spew his crap.

[TheRealDeal]

:lol: There is nothing wrong with being proud of your race and who you are but that has nothing to do with how I view players.

I'd take Cam over a lot of whites. Palko, Painter, The Golden Calf of Bristol, Beck to name a few.

Keep on with your with your thing though, I do enjoy reading all your posts.

[TheRealDeal]

The old "character assassination" trick eh?

[ItsNotGonnaBeAlright]

Ok wait....you criticize Newton in the past for not leading his team to a larger number of victories, not being productive in the fourth quarter, not being reliable in the red zone, not pulling out the "clutch" come-from-behind victory in the final moments of a game....and the gleefully say that you'll take Newton over The Golden Calf of Bristol?

I really want to hear your critique of The Golden Calf of Bristol now. C'mon, give me some stats.

[TheRealDeal]

Only if you quote these imaginary posts I made.

[TheRealDeal]

And if you can watch The Golden Calf of Bristol play a football game and say you'd take him over Cam, you should cut your dick and balls off because you shouldn't be allowed to reproduce.

The Golden Calf of Bristol is borderline Jimmy Clausen bad. His own coach and team president hate him. Eventually in the NFL you have to be able to throw the ball to win consistently, that time just hasn't come for him yet. Don't be short sighted.

[mav1234]

Back on topic, if you are a Panthers fan you should vote for Cam.

meh... I like Cam but I may vote for Peterson because I think he had an epic day. Cam does good things and deserves the credit he gets, but I think what PP did was more impressive this week. Just my opinion, and people are free to disagree with it.

[TheRealDeal]

You are a white racist, Mav.

[ItsNotGonnaBeAlright]

No

[TheRealDeal]

Because I've never said most of what you said I said in that post where you said I said all those things.

Pretty sure I only said Cam didn't have a lot of the tools to be a successful NFL QB, which he is improving upon and proving me wrong. I questioned things that deserved to be questioned based on the facts at hand and the perception that I was a hater and a racist grew from there.

I'm very proud of my race but I'm not a bigot.