Cam up for Rookie of the Week again...

[CatMan72]

You're assuming all Panther fans ONLY voted for Cam and all Bengals fans ONLY voted for Dalton and no other NFL fans voted.

Silly.

No, I'm assuming there is very little validity to a poll that allows individuals to vote an unlimited # of times.

[mav1234]

what validity is there to any award that is solely decided by letting people on the internet vote for anyway?

[CRA]

270 yds 1 TD > 261 yds 1 TD

Not always.....stats lie. Didn't watch Dalton so I have no idea but Sam Bradford last season is a perfect example of a QB not making tough throws and accumulating stats.

[Gazi]

If Cam was in Cincy the Bungals would have been 2 games ahead of Steelers and Ravens in that division.

[mav1234]

Not always.....stats lie. Didn't watch Dalton so I have no idea but Sam Bradford last season is a perfect example of a QB not making tough throws and accumulating stats.

can't comment on the toughness of the throws made or how big an impact YAC had, but Dalton's YPA was respectable (better than Cam's) this last game.

If Cam was in Cincy the Bungals would have been 2 games ahead of Steelers and Ravens in that division.

That would mean they were 10 and 1 and the 2nd best team in the NFL. Sorry, but I don't think that Cam alone would make THAT big a difference.

I do not think that Dalton has no weapons, but I do think our offense is certainly much more "stacked" than his is, especially when it comes to an OC willing to air the ball out.

I do think we'd have a ton more wins with their defense, but I am not sure how much different switching the QBs would be. I do think Cam is a better quarterback from what I have seen so far, but I do not think that it is such a huge gap as to translate into what you think it would.

[Sword]

Dalton also lost a fumble, which according to certain people around here is a reason not to get Rookie of the Week :P

[GritsRgreat]

Dalton also lost a fumble, which according to certain people around here is a reason not to get Rookie of the Week :P

Only if it costs a win. Daltons fumble didn't. :P

[Gazi]

motherfuger, do you have an alert setup for posts in this thread? your ass is quick :lol:

[mav1234]

I didn't blame Cam for the fumbles against Minnesota really so it's hard for me to blame Dalton without having seen it. There are times when a fumble is a QB's fault and other times where it's a good play by the defender.

[mav1234]

Only if it costs a win. Daltons fumble didn't. :P

Which of Cam's fumbles cost the Panthers a win? We held a lead after Cam's fumbles vs Minnesota.

[holderoftruth]

If Cam was in Cincy the Bungals would have been 2 games ahead of Steelers and Ravens in that division.

Its unfair to do that swap. Dalton wasnt drafted with their first pick. If you sway Dalton and Newton you have to take away AJ Green from the Bengals, because you are giving the Bengals two top five picks.

[Gazi]

I'm talking about situations here.

[GritsRgreat]

Which of Cam's fumbles cost the Panthers a win? We held a lead after Cam's fumbles vs Minnesota.

Both fumbles lead to Minnesota scores. The Vikings on their own weren't scoring that many points. They were gifts. Panthers win without those turnovers.

[Gazi]

And I'm happy for Dalton and and Ponder. This is a great QB class. Also happy for The Golden Calf of Bristol, especially because we were in the same situation with the haters who constantly busted on Cam and called him a bust before he even had a chance.