Cam up for Rookie of the Week again...

[Moose87Banks]

If Matt Moore is better than Cam, why did we let him go to Miami? We could have re-signed him.

[X-Clown]

lol, TRD who is always telling everyone that their opinions are wrong and are based upon what ESPN says now is saying that we should base our evaluations of QB play on a formula that ESPN created. You can't even make this stuff up.

[bauss]

after reading some of the stupid poo in this thread, im actually kind of surprised some of you haven't died to Darwinism

Not to get too technical but Darwin's evolutionary theory isn't a disease you can die from.

But yes, I agree. TRD is definitely stupid beyond logic.

[TheRealDeal]

I would hate facts too if I was wrong by their standards

[CRA]

I would hate facts too if I was wrong by their standards

facts....they are a funny things. People think b/c they say X it means X is factually true.

[CRA]

The experts disagree.

Like everyone is choosing to ignore because it hurts their soul, the experts agree Moore is playing better than Newton to this day. Newton might have a higher ceiling, but Moore is clearly the better QB right now, despite all of Newton's hype.

It says a lot about Moore that he's able to rally teams with losing records and make them relevant, make other teams fear them, make them contenders, get the best out of his teammates, elevate everyone's play.

This is something Cam Newton has not found a way to do.

or maybe Miami just has a signifantly better defense and special teams.....which allows Moore to be a roleplayer as Miami wins some games.

Let's ignore the fact the Miami D has allowed an average of 6 pts per game in Moore's wins. Reality is no fun to talk about.

[TheRealDeal]

Miami's D has been great since Moore got in there. He inspires his teammates to play better and they want to play for him, he's a true leader. He elevates everyone's play, did it in 2007, 2009, and now in 2011.

Not sure how him being a role player leads to him putting up great numbers and converting big third downs, big red zone trips, etc unless you are trying to argue some PFFL type poo.

[The_Mango55]

Miami's D has been great since Moore got in there. He inspires his teammates to play better and they want to play for him, he's a true leader. He elevates everyone's play, did it in 2007, 2009, and now in 2011.

Oh you mean like The Golden Calf of Bristol?! :)

[TheRealDeal]

Moore backs up that leadership and belief with real NFL QBing. The Golden Calf of Bristol does not.

Imagine a talented The Golden Calf of Bristol that actually knows what a vagina feels like...............................................................................................................................you have just imagined Matt Moore.

[The_Mango55]

Why didn't he elevate anyone's game in 2010 I wonder?

[TheRealDeal]

He had a concussion then an injury...the owner purged the team of even college level talent, he cut the legs out from the coach, he tried his hardest to save every dollar he could. Players knew it, coaches knew it, people in Egypt knew it. Dwayne Jarrett was starting on opening day. Yes, that Dwayne Jarrett.

Perfect storm of a season right there coupled with the limited sample size and you have your anomaly.

[-13 Amp-]

Moore backs up that leadership and belief with real NFL QBing. The Golden Calf of Bristol does not.

Imagine a talented The Golden Calf of Bristol that actually knows what a vagina feels like...............................................................................................................................you have just imagined Matt Moore.

The Golden Calf of Bristol beat Moore though, so by your logic, The Golden Calf of Bristol is better

[Peppers90 NC]

wow, a rookie of the week thread is getting this much attention.... my how far "Occupy Huddle" has fallen.

[TheRealDeal]

lol okay