Newton vs Dalton...who's better after 8 games?

[Gazi]

Hey i didn't start the thread and i've stayed on topic so i don't believe i'm trolling.

I ain't mad at cha. If they let you troll them, then oh well.

[TheOracle]

Dalton has more passing TDs, more interceptions, Newton has more Total TDs, more total yards.

Wins are irrelevant in the comparison, since the ability of a Defense to stop other teams has to be considered in "Wins/Loses" and the Panthers' defense couldn't stop a plastic bag from blowing across the field.

If they gave Dalton ROY right now, after today, I wouldn't have a problem with it.

[SOJA]

this has its own fuging forum

[PaulSoleil]

Seems that Newt gets all the press, but Dalton is impressive as well.

Dalton. Just for the sheer fact that Newton's got 3 pro-bowl targets (shockey, olsen and smith - yes olsen was selected as an alternate) and 2 once dominant runners, and an offense that built around his skill set and still can't win.

let's face it, this is as good as the offense is going to get as far as personelle. it'll only go downhill from this point.

dalton has more wins with less to work with.

heck, The Golden Calf of Bristol even has more wins and he's got basically bottom tier targets over there