Newton vs Dalton...who's better after 8 games?

[Jangler]

Well for this year, Dalton's success is directly proportionate to Newton's failure. The NFL is a bias league, I would hate it if we go 3-13 and Cam doesn't get OROY.

Need to get over that one too, if the Bengals make the playoffs, but that is a big if, Dalton will get it.

[GritsRgreat]

because that's one of the games we actually won. But you have strayed from your logic. Dalton loses, you give him props. Newton loses despite playing great, you give him none and actually bash him. Double standard, hypocritical bullsh**.

I give Dalton props for leading his team to a winning record when everyone thought they would have the no. 1 pick in next seasons draft. Whats so bad about that?

LOL Eagles just lost!

[Guest]

I give Dalton props for leading his team to a winning record when everyone thought that would have the no. 1 pick in next seasons draft. Whats so bad about that?

LOL Eagles just lost!

so has dalton been playing defense or are you just giving credit to the wrong person(s) to serve your own bias?

[GritsRgreat]

my point is that cam has been objectively better than dalton this year, so there must be some sort of "external" factor at work here

i mean are you just dumb or.......

I liked Dalton before the draft. Thought he would make a good NFL QB. Glad to see i was right.

[GritsRgreat]

so has dalton been playing defense or are you just giving credit to the wrong person(s) to serve your own bias?

They had a pretty good defense last season so why were they picking so high?

[davos]

so the mods instantly delete another typical TCF thread but this poo is up to 90 posts?

f*ck that

[KillerKat]

I give Dalton props for leading his team to a winning record when everyone thought they would have the no. 1 pick in next seasons draft. Whats so bad about that?

LOL Eagles just lost!

Your arguement has always been about giving props to QBs who win.

Dalton didn't win today. He played poorly. But you still give him props.

When Newton has played great, but still loses you hate on him.

This defies your logic. Therefore you have a bias. Therefore your opinion holds no water.

Your arguement was never about the bengals current overall record. You're changing your arguement now to try to save face.

You don't bash Dalton when he plays bad in a loss, but bash Newon when he plays great in a loss.

You're logic is fragmented.

[mav1234]

man I liked TCF's thread too, I think it had some real potential... ;)

[YoungPanthers89]

Can a mod at least put this in the proper section?

[Davidson Deac II]

my point is that cam has been objectively better than dalton this year, so there must be some sort of "external" factor at work here

i mean are you just dumb or.......

I think Cam has been great, better than Dalton. But how can you possibly claim that its dumb to say that Dalton has been better? An objective person could easily make the argument for either one of them. I think Cam has been overall better because of his scrambling and his ability to throw the deep ball. But, it could easily be argued that Dalton has been better because he has more wins, a better completion percentage, and a better td to interception ratio.

Seems to me you are just trying to bait here, and not making an honest attempt to debate.

[GritsRgreat]

I thought my argument has always been about winning? Thats no saying Dalton or anyone else would win every game of the season.

[Jangler]

Your arguement has always been about giving props to QBs who win.

Dalton didn't win today. He played poorly. But you still give him props.

When Newton has played great, but still loses you hate on him.

This defies your logic. Therefore you have a bias. Therefore your opinion holds no water.

Your arguement was never about the bengals current overall record. You're changing your arguement now to try to save face.

You don't bash Dalton when he plays bad in a loss, but bash Newon when he plays great in a loss.

You're logic is fragmented.

Yeah, I have not wanted to say it or see it, but it has to be fear of the black QB and rooting for a team that has one.

[Gazi]

Dalton stunk up the place. Good thread. NOT

[Jangler]

Can a mod at least put this in the proper section?

sorry, no septic tanks on site.