Newton vs Dalton...who's better after 8 games?

[Guest]

you'd have to be one dumb motherfuger to think that dalton has been better than cam

Sorry son but that ball was thrown right on the money between two defenders. Please give the passer some credit.

i rest my case

[footballisasport]

Cam started off great but the wheels run off today. Dalton has a better card all the way around. Now would you take Cam or a Dalton/AJ Green combo?

Wrong...u really haven't been watching the Bengals have u. Dalton is surround by a MUCH better team. Period. He can afford to suck and he will still have a chance to win. Cam has a so/so day and his team suck even more. Cam has a spetacular day and his team still find a way to lose...End of the discussion.

[GritsRgreat]

You are an epic troll. Where was this sh** when Cam was putting up great numbers and we were still losing in tight games? You were too busy sucking Dalton's balls to say anything nice about Newton. Cincy is losing, but you are still gay for Dalton. When the Panthers lose, you could care less about Cam you hypocritical bastard.

Personal attacks are uncalled for. I haven't said one word against Cam.

[KillerKat]

Personal attacks are uncalled for. I haven't said one word against Cam.

When we were losing you thought nothing of Cam despite him putting up great numbers. Dalton is losing while putting up not so good numbers and you are giving him props.

Cam has the best first 2 games of any rookie in NFL history despite losing

Grits: "He didn't win *slurp slurp slurp* Dalton is better*

Dalton has 50% completion percentage and losing

Grits: "Dalton is ROY!"

[footballisasport]

Wow..Even Blaine Gabbert is winning. See what happens when u have a decent defense. Ur offense really doesn't have to be spectacular. Ur QB doesn't always have to play lights out week in and out..

[Jangler]

Sounds like we have some new Bengals fans here. so GTFO!

[mav1234]

Wrong...u really haven't been watching the Bengals have u. Dalton is surround by a MUCH better team. Period. He can afford to suck and he will still have a chance to win. Cam has a so/so day and his team suck even more. Cam has a spetacular day and his team still find a way to lose.

cam has been worse than so-so today.

but other than that, Dalton has been playing well. He's had only one really bad day and they lost that game, so the team can't carry them that much

Dalton is as much a part of the wins that team has been getting as any other unit. He's keeping them in the game. But he also just threw a pick, so.

[FugginPoo]

Cam is 18/34 with OL and overall team playing like crap

Dalton is 14/28 with his team playing well

[bleys]

you'd have to be one dumb motherf**ker to think that dalton has been better than cam

:lol:

/thread

[mav1234]

Wow..Even Blaine Gabbert is winning. See what happens when u have a decent defense. Ur offense really doesn't have to be spectacular. Ur QB doesn't always have to play lights out week in and out..

today is one day you are wrong... our defense has played much better today than it usually does.

they had a very very bad drive to start the day, but since then they have held the Titans to field goals, even given some short fields and what not.

defense hasn't been *great*, but it has been good enough to win. Our offense, though...

[Davidson Deac II]

The only decent teams the Bungholes have faced are the Niners and the Bills. They've played the Colts, Titans, Jags, Seahawks, Browns and Broncos in their other games.

Our own schedule hasn't exactly been filled with NFL powerhouses.

[bleys]

today is one day you are wrong... our defense has played much better today than it usually does.

they had a very very bad drive to start the day, but since then they have held the Titans to field goals, even given some short fields and what not.

defense hasn't been *great*, but it has been good enough to win. Our offense, though...

agreed.. and Chris Johnson's stats have been padded late in this game..

[Swarly]

our d/st gave up 17 points in the first q... that is not playing well.

[mav1234]

our d/st gave up 17 points in the first q... that is not playing well.

did *not* say ST played well

said the defense picked it up compared to usual...

They gave up 7 points in the first quarter, then didn't allow any TDs after that (barring anything that may come from this drive at the end of the game here).

Defense DID play better, much better. They forced punts, got a turnover, but our offense couldn't do anything with it.