Newton vs. Tebow

[CarolinaCatBrigade]

Alright, so I have an ignorant and very loud Broncos fan in my dorm. When we are fugged up on some type of substance we always talk crap about eachothers teams.

He honestly believes The Golden Calf of Bristol is better than Cam Newton, just because The Golden Calf of Bristol has more wins. Even though Cam Newton blows him away with skill set and talent, apparently The Golden Calf of Bristol is just hands down the better QB (if a QB is what you call him).

He says that The Golden Calf of Bristol is the most talked about QB on ESPN and other networks, not Newton. Even though I'm pretty sure that's because it's a bye week for Carolina. But does The Golden Calf of Bristol have his picture in the background on Fox NFL gameday news casts? Nope! Does Chuck Norris wear The Golden Calf of Bristol underwear? Nope!

So everyone, what is your perspective on this comparison? Honestly there isn't much of anything between the two other than what's popular among the fans on two losing teams. But for sh*ts and giggles let me hear what you have to say.

Cam Newton > Most NFL QB's > College QB's > The Golden Calf of Bristol

[dpm0409]

Alright, so I have an ignorant and very loud Broncos fan in my dorm. When we are fugged up on some type of substance we always talk crap about eachothers teams.

He honestly believes The Golden Calf of Bristol is better than Cam Newton, just because The Golden Calf of Bristol has more wins. Even though Cam Newton blows him away with skill set and talent, apparently The Golden Calf of Bristol is just hands down the better QB (if a QB is what you call him).

He says that The Golden Calf of Bristol is the most talked about QB on ESPN and other networks, not Newton. Even though I'm pretty sure that's because it's a bye week for Carolina. But does The Golden Calf of Bristol have his picture in the background on Fox NFL gameday news casts? Nope! Does Chuck Norris wear The Golden Calf of Bristol underwear? Nope!

So everyone, what is your perspective on this comparison? Honestly there isn't much of anything between the two other than what's popular among the fans on two losing teams. But for sh*ts and giggles let me hear what you have to say.

Cam Newton > Most NFL QB's > College QB's > The Golden Calf of Bristol

Don't they both have 2 currently??

[CarolinaCatBrigade]

Don't they both have 2 currently??

Broncos are 3-5, but he's talking about career wins.

[Lumps]

Point him to the record books where Cam is the best rookie QB in the NFL of all time in most categories and basically in general.

The Golden Calf of Bristol is in his second year and sat for a year. He should be lighting Cam the fug up.

Anyone who compares them is stupid and who the fug cares about comparing college. NFL is all that is needed, that's where things get hard.

I cannot stand this comparison or any comparison to Cam. He is setting records for being the best rookie QB all over the place, he cannot be compared to anyone but if he was it needs to be a rookie, but even still setting records means you don't compare to anyone.

[BigSyke]

trent dilfer has a super bowl win but dan marino doesnt

FAILLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!

[Camdemonium]

Good old drunk college dorm arguments.

[Camdemonium]

Anybody remember the days when dudes in college chased pussy instead of get drunk and debate their favorite QB?

[CRA]

The Golden Calf of Bristol currently has 2 wins.....Cam has 2. Let's review the difference in the wins.

1. Cam has played great

2. The Broncos found a way to win 2 games despite horrific QB play.

The Golden Calf of Bristol completes 26% of his passes when asked to throw past 10 yards. He is a running back he occassionally throws.

[CPF4LIFE]

trent dilfer has a super bowl win but dan marino doesnt

FAILLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!

This logic alone should shut up any Cam vs Dalton, The Golden Calf of Bristol talk.

[Camdemonium]

So are you saying QB is irrelevant when it comes to Wins/Losses?

[Lumps]

and on the wins, for the most part wins are stupid to talk about unless you're comparing teams not individual players.

[CRA]

So are you saying QB is irrelevant when it comes to Wins/Losses?

He is saying what most know....wins and losses are a team stat. not an individual one.

[Camdemonium]

Stats are stupid to talk about as well unless you consider everything else.

Too many times we look the other way when it's favorable then throw condition after condition when it's not. Whatever it may be, look at the big picture.

[CatMan72]

Get back to me when The Golden Calf of Bristol throws for 400+ yards.