Rank Panthers top 5 QBs- Alltime (Cam?)

[bLACKpANTHER]

As of right now... not potential down the road..

1.Delhomme

2.Cam

3.Beuerlein

4.Collins

5.Peete

[Mr. Scot]

Too soon to put Newton above Beuerlein.

[fieryprophet]

I would honestly put Cam #3 just based on body of work, below Beurlein at #2 and Delhomme at #1

This will probably be different by the end of the year.

[PhillyB]

jake is 89th on the all-time passing yardage list with 20,764

kerry collins is number 10 all time with 40,922

cam has the potential to be top ten in that statistic if he stays healthy and has a long career, but let's not crown him just yet. give it a season at least.

[Chimera]

considering only 3 have been worth a hoot,

1 Jake

2 Bnottryingtospellhisnamerightnow

3 Cam

4-12 (tied) Vinny T, Matt Moore, Jimmy C, Kerry Collins, D Craig, D Carr, R Peete, Chris W, F Reich

[hepcat]

#1 - Jake

#2 - Beuerlein

#3 - Cam

#4 - Collins

#5 - who the F cares

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Collins is still probably ahead of Cam seeing as how the dude has started 8 games.

No love for Brian St. Pierre or Randy Fasani?

[scarface]

1. Cam

....the rest are irrelevant

[panthers55]

Based on actual production Cam would be below jake, Steve, Kerry and Rodney. If you look at their first 8 games he would be right there with Jake, and Steve. If you list based on ability to be a franchise QB then he might be all alone.

[Duncan81]

Only way Jake is even in the convo is a young Steve Smith going up and gettin his overthrown passes

[nosuchthingasapanther]

i can barely name 5 panthers' qbs.

[4Corners]

ummmmm where the hell is Randy Fasani

[Chimera]

Only way Jake is even in the convo is a young Steve Smith going up and gettin his overthrown passes

2004 stats:

Jake Delhomme 3886 yards, 29 TD, 87.3 rating

Steve Smith 6 catches, 60 yards, 0 TD

just sayin....

[panthers55]

Only way Jake is even in the convo is a young Steve Smith going up and gettin his overthrown passes

Yeah because Smitty makes any quarterback good. Just look at Carr and Jimmy and Matt.

Oh wait....

Nevermind......