nfl.com article cam rookie season falls short of best ever

[usmcpanthers]

this article is a bunch of poo...the season isnt even over yet. The comparsions are apples and oranges. It at says at this pace cam will have the best rookie qb season ever.

IMO a great rookie qb is much better then any other rookie position player.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/09000d5d823aec5f/article/newtons-rookie-season-falls-short-of-best-ever-in-nfl

[fieryprophet]

Meh, I'll take greatest QB season. It's much easier for other position players to dominate immediately, no shame in that.

[teeray]

I posted this yesterday. It was exciting that he wasn't be compared to other rookie QBs but rookie players at all positions.

[JawnyBlaze]

Yea, I can definitely see the argument against best rookie season by a player ever. But he'll definitely be talked about in the conversation for a long time, and be a prime candidate for best rookie season by a QB ever (the most difficult transition and position to excel at as a rookie).

[ed bell]

Except for Edgerrin James (Manning's coattails?), all HOF players, so not fair to say they shouldn't have been included, but it's hard to say when different positions are involved. I'd agree that LT's (original) was a stellar performance......and no QB's even made that list, so it's Newton's to lose at this point as far as QB's go.

[rayzor]

i don't have a problem with this.

a panthers QB is in the discussion...legitimately! who would have thunk it?