Newton versus Luck

[flpantherfan32137]

This is a very interesting and short read on CBSSPORTS.com. I like what they had to say, it was a very interesting discussion. Cam wins 4-2 :) http://www.cbssports.com/mcc/blogs/entry/22475988/33078939

By the way, I haven't seen this posted yet. If it was, please disregard. Thanks

[Camdemonium]

I wonder when they will start comparing our #1 pick to NFL QBs.

[Verge]

There is nothing to compare. Newton is the greatest rookie qb of all time and Luck is a college prospect who has never won anything.

[Guest Irv]

There is nothing to compare. Newton is the greatest rookie qb of all time and Luck is a college prospect who has never won anything.

:iagree:

[Verge]

Hey guys, lets compare Joe Montana and Blaine Gabbert.

WHY?

[Swarly]

I wonder when they will start comparing our #1 pick to NFL QBs.

They are.

They compared Luck to Peyton.

Now they're comparing Cam to Luck, and saying Cam > Luck

In conclusion, Cam > Peyton.

[flpantherfan32137]

They are.

They compared Luck to Peyton.

Now they're comparing Cam to Luck, and saying Cam > Luck

In conclusion, Cam > Peyton.

IMHO 10 years from now, this will likely be the case. Cam brings so much to the game beyond just being a strong armed pocket passer.

[TruCatzFan]

They are.

They compared Luck to Peyton.

Now they're comparing Cam to Luck, and saying Cam > Luck

In conclusion, Cam > Peyton.

This is actually a very true statement.

[BBQ&Beer]

I wonder when they will start comparing our #1 pick to NFL QBs.

They did, Russell, (Vince) Young, some even pointed to Leaf. They were so wildly wrong that they now are scrambling to find someone to compare him too...

Only ones that make sense are Luck & Superman. They have to go with Luck because Supes wouldn't be fair since he has weaknesses such as a red sun & kryptonite... Also... He's fictitious.

[beastson]

Im so tired of hearing or reading about this kid. I wish ppl stop comparing him and Cam. Luck is still in college. How about compare other college QB's to him

[rippadonn]

He beat Luck for the Heisman. As far as they were concerned Cam Newton was the better player THE best player in college that year, not Luck. Those guys know more football than anybody here.

[The_Mango55]

I'm not at this time willing to say that Cam will ever be better than Peyton at his peak. Peyton could not only make all the throws but also drove the offense in a way no other NFL QB can.

But Newton will be amazing, no doubt about that.

He beat Luck for the Heisman. As far as they were concerned Cam Newton was the better player THE best player in college that year, not Luck. Those guys know more football than anybody here.

Eeeeeehhh, Heisman doesn't always go to the best player. It usually goes to the QB or RB (whichever is more famous/prominent) on the best team. Jason White was never the best player in the country.

[beckersteen]

One of the Mikes on M&M in the morning thinks Cam throws better and moves around better. He doesn't believe Luck will be better than Cam.

[Rubi]

Id love to see Stanford in the Natl Title game and get crushed by Bama or LSU. Then maybe people will shut up about Andrew F*ck