Terry Bradshaw ranked Dalton ahead of Cam...

[Dpantherman]

Let me ask you a question, is Alex Smith better than Ryan Fitzpatrick or Matt Shaub?

[Disinfranchised]

Bradshaw, he bald head , he bald head and he pittsbugg steelers can eat poo and die.

[mav1234]

Cam is the better rookie, no doubt in my mind, but our entire offense is better than the Bengals' offense.

Their defense is better than ours.

Their special teams is better than ours.

They are a better team than we are.

If the voting was held today, Cam would win.

But if it was held after playoff spots were determined, and if the Bengals are in the playoffs and Dalton continues to play well and the Panthers are still largely held out of the win columns, I can see why Dalton might win as RotY.

But right now? Cam.

[Grammer]

We lost to a 1-6 team today, don't try to think, you will hurt yourself

you do know wins are a team thing right? when your defense sucks dick like ours, you won't win games. dalton has a great defense and a shitty schedule

once dalton plays pittsburgh and the ravens, i think the red head nuthugging will calm down

[holderoftruth]

Anyone that watches Cam play realizes this kid is going to be special. Just have to give the Panthers time to put better pieces around Cam and the wins will start to come.

[footballisasport]

The huddlers hate gingers as many other people in this country do. Why do you think all these people blame Axl Rose for the demise of Guns 'N Roses?

Bradshaw is brave to throw his support behind gingers who have been considered subhuman far too long in this country.

The question I need to ask is, how come Cam had a similair day to Matthew Stafford and come out on the losing end of the game? Stafford's Lions 45 over Bronco 10.. The importance of a good defense and secondary. Who knew.

[stirs]

Read the post again.

I said that you can expect to hear this kind of stuff because both went to teams with top 5 picks in last years draft, making them crappy teams in my opinion.

One team is 5-2 with a second round QB, and the other is 2-6 with the top guy in the entire draft. You can expect to hear that Dalton is overachieving. I did not say he was the better QB, schoolchildren.

My dad can beat up your dad.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

"hey guys I don't know about you but I'll take the gritty fourth quarter comeback artist over the flashy guy who piles up stats but isn't clutch and isn't winning"

-Panthers fans to Saints fans, 2008

[Dilla]

Look at the Bengals-Seahawks game today. . .

Andy Dalton: 18/29 for 168 with 2 TDs and 2 interceptions, yet the Bengals win 34-12. Crappy team last year or not, the Bengals are a better team overall now.

[stirs]

Read the post again.

I said that you can expect to hear this kind of stuff because both went to teams with top 5 picks in last years draft, making them crappy teams in my opinion.

One team is 5-2 with a second round QB, and the other is 2-6 with the top guy in the entire draft. You can expect to hear that Dalton is overachieving. I did not say he was the better QB, schoolchildren.

My dad can beat up your dad.

[Shonuff]

"hey guys I don't know about you but I'll take the gritty fourth quarter comeback artist over the flashy guy who piles up stats but isn't clutch and isn't winning"

-Panthers fans to Saints fans, 2008

Truthfully, Cam isn't flashy and quite gritty, things haven't worked out in the close games but the trees will fall...I like this offense, gotta get Dwill involved, somehow.

[Guest]

Bradshaw, he bald head , he bald head and he pittsbugg steelers can eat poo and die.

qft

[Disinfranchised]

qft

Preciate that.

[footballisasport]

Cam is the better rookie, no doubt in my mind, but our entire offense is better than the Bengals' offense.

Their defense is better than ours.

Their special teams is better than ours.

They are a better team than we are.

If the voting was held today, Cam would win.

But if it was held after playoff spots were determined, and if the Bengals are in the playoffs and Dalton continues to play well and the Panthers are still largely held out of the win columns, I can see why Dalton might win as RotY.

But right now? Cam.

U're not being totally honest...The Panthers offense is not as consistant as the Bengals. Andy has people he can turn to week in and out. Cam has about three vets around him who are very good but it's clear the coaches are pushing him to give the ball more to receivers who aren't very consistant.

I like all three QBs, and I believed these guys were much better QBs than given credit for during the draft. But let's be honest, Cam has the talliest mountain to climb out of the three rookies. And he seems more taken for granted than given help. Those rookie QBs can mess up and still have their teams pull out a win. It's clearly not the case with Cam.