Terry Bradshaw ranked Dalton ahead of Cam...

[the butch]

go cam

[antame]

Bradshaw's silly.

Dalton averages a measly 6.8 YPA, which ranks 20th in the league. 17th in over 20, 14th in over 40 and his QB rating is 18th. Which ranks behind McNabb who was just benched for Ponder.

Cam's numbers are better in YPA, over 20, over 40, QB rating, yards and TD's. They also have comparable numbers in turnovers, yet the offense that Cam Newton runs is much more of a riskier offense and takes the most over 20 shots per game in the NFL.

I'd say that Bradshaw is silly, it takes a team to win games. Cam's number's smash and put Dalton's to shame.

They are, but Dalton has looked pretty damn good, and I don't recall anyone talking about the freakin' Bengals being a playoff team pre-season. He's winning, which is ultimately the measure.

So far this year, I think Dalton might be slightly better than Cam. Longer term, I'm very happy with Cam. No reason to get excited here.

[SoSportz]

Cam is having a great year and I wouldn't put any rookie ahead of him. We can all see his playmaking ability and will to win. The record may not show it but this kid is special. We are in a tough conference but in a few years the Panthers will be the team people are talking about. http://sosportz.blogspot.com

-@SoSportz

[necroplasm]

talking about those 2 fumbles...lol 2nd time, gross got burned. i believe some of the blind hate is from bitter cocks fans, etc. not just trollin.so with that said, who gives a poo about ncaa when it comes to cam newton now? he is a panther...so shat up, let it go!

bro...

[necroplasm]

talking about those 2 fumbles...lol 2nd time, gross got burned. so that's not even debatable.

i believe some of the blind hate is from bitter cocks fans, etc. not just trollin.so with that said, who gives a poo about ncaa when it comes to cam newton now? he is a panther...so shat up, let it go!

bro...

[Kevin Greene]

This fugging thread is still going? Who cares if Dalton is Peyton Manning and Johnny Unitas' love child?

Only thing that matters is Cam helping us win games.

Cam is certailny holding up his end.

[Kevin Greene]

Cam is having a great year and I wouldn't put any rookie ahead of him. We can all see his playmaking ability and will to win. The record may not show it but this kid is special. We are in a tough conference but in a few years the Panthers will be the team people are talking about. http://sosportz.blogspot.com

-@SoSportz

Kissing ass to get people to click your link ftw, :lol:

[ItsPantone278]

Shot old Terry an E-mail! I know I did!

http://msn.foxsports.com/talent/Terry_Bradshaw

[necroplasm]

You should make a pact with yourself to never attempt a sane debate with someone who considers "wins" a QB statistic.

argument should have ended here. ^^^

[X-Clown]

3000 yards, 60% comp, 21 TD, 13 INT is mediocre?

He was 18th in completion percentage, behind guys like Jason Campbell, Chad Henne, David Garrard and Joe Flacco

18th in passing yardage, again behind Campbell, Flacco, Garrard, etc.

Tied for 15th in TD passes

20th in yards per attempt behind the likes of Sanchez, Vince Young, Campbell, Garrard, Flacco

16th in passer rating behind more of the usual suspects

Then of course the playoff game where he went 18 of 36 for 146 yards and a 58.3 rating.

Which would all be fine if we were talking about a guy who was a rookie, but it's Carson Palmer who was being paid like a top 5 QB.

[The_Mango55]

Give this defense a Stud DT or corner and a 2nd round QB and....we're 7-1.

Which stud DT or corner from this year's draft are you talking about?

What have you seen out of Dalton that shows he has any chance of carrying this team?

[fitty76]

Anyone who puts Andy Daulton over Cam because of WINS is an idiot and knows nothing about football.

[Pox 08]

Anyone who puts Andy Daulton over Cam because of WINS is an idiot and knows nothing about football.

You know how some people are. Wins are the only thing that matters when judging rookie qbs.

[bigcatdaddy]

You know how some people are. Wins are the only thing that matters when judging rookie qbs.

But it can't be it is a team game, the way to judge any player is by how good they play. That would be like saying Trent Dilfer went 11-1 with the Ravens in 2000 when they won the Superbowl so he was the best QB in the league. We all know thats BS he had 1500 yards and 12 TD's and 11 ints. Dalton has a better special team and a better defense plus an easy schedule so far, he is not even the best rookie on that team, Green is.