ESPN Picks Between Newton & Luck

[rippadonn]

F ESPN the Heisman committee already wrestled with this one and they chose Cam over Luck last year. The choice is obvious. Luck is an unproven NFL prospect and chose to remain so.

[Grammer]

lol at idiots trying to discredit luck

5-5 75 yards and a td on stanfords first drive

[Jangler]

meh who gives a poo. I hope Luck is a good NFL QB, that way Cam and Luck can have a 10 year rivalry in the Superbowl.

[The_Mango55]

lol at idiots trying to discredit luck

5-5 75 yards and a td on stanfords first drive

against an unranked team on probation

[Grammer]

against an unranked team on probation

could you please inform me on how he could do better?

[mav1234]

well he's throw like, 3 incompletions so far. ;)

nah luck is a great prospect, I'm just happy with Cam.

[Grammer]

meh who gives a poo. I hope Luck is a good NFL QB, that way Cam and Luck can have a 10 year rivalry in the Superbowl.

he's going to the afc most likely, hopefully they can play against each other in the super bowl

[GritsRgreat]

Barkley meh

[PantherFanOne]

Give me Cam Newton,,,,Hands down...No questions asked.

[Montsta]

I love me some Cam Newton, and I couldn't be happier that we got him. But you guys that are trying to discredit Luck are just nuts. No pocket presence? The only reason why he takes off so often is because dude is deceptively fast and when he see the defense stretched out and knows he can get an easy 12 yards on a scramble, he takes it. Luck is the real deal, and when he and Cam go toe to toe in the NFCCG or the SB over the next 15 years, it will be some of the best football any of us will get to see as Panthers fans.

[GritsRgreat]

Imma name my next son Lucky.

[The_Mango55]

Imma name my next son Lucky.

Except you'll tell him it's for Andrew Luck, but it's actually a reference to you finding a chick that let you put it in her.

[DawgzLife]

Luck needs to be knocked dwon a few pegs just b/c of his elitest mentality. He & his dad are looking like Eli Manning & his dad. They want to 'pick' the team he goes to.

I would take Cam everyday...he is happy to be here & is proving everyone wrong.

Luck is great (no doubt), but I hope he proves everyone wrong the opposite direction form Cam, b/c I do not like players who feel entitled to decide who they will play for as rookie.

[DawgzLife]

The only reason why he takes off so often is because dude is deceptively fast and when he see the defense stretched out and knows he can get an easy 12 yards on a scramble, he takes it.

This is the only thing I 'disagree' (used loosely) with you on. Luck is fast & doesn't look deceptive to me. Cam is deceptive in his speed b/c he is so big he doesn't look like he's moving that fast.

I don't see how any Panther fan (& I'm not saying you are Montsta) can look over the fact that Luck consciously decided against coming to Carolina. I hate Luck since that decision (it wasn't for a Championship or anything else...he was 'choosing' where to go). I hope he fails, but doubt that will happen.