After 7 games, is Cam already a.....

[SmootsDaddy89]

nope he has illegally raped to many ppl to be top tier

As opposed to legal rape, which is AWESOME. *brofist*

[scarface]

Best list in this thread, with one exception....

I like Manning but Manning is not an NFL QB this year, he is a spectator. Keep him off the lists until he is back playing.

Cam is easily in the top half of NFL starting QB's and possibly in the top 10.

Could you honestly tell me based on his first 7 games that you would prefer Romo or Cutler to Cam? I agree it's debatable based on his game experience, but right now, I'd much rather have Cam than all of the QB's on that list minus the first 5. If he keeps playing like he is, he'll move up there too.

Romo & Cutler were ahead of Cam simply because of their seniority and their play in the past proved they were good QBs.

Based on this season alone I'd have Cam at #6 or #7.

Based on skill and future potential he'd be #1b, tied with A. Rod.

P. Manning is the greatest QB I've ever seen and hes not retired (yet),so technically still in the NFL.

Also I forgot to add the other Manning. He has a ring after all.

[Keith Moons Liver]

why would you put Freeman in the top 10? he's got a 73 QB rating, 10 interceptions, and has been a pretty major disappointment this season. Cam is absolutely better than Freeman.

it's pretty much Brady/Rodgers/Brees in the top tier, then Cam is somewhere in that second tier, below Ben/Rivers/etc. Give it a few seasons and he could be in that top tier.

cam has been better this season but freeman was fantastic last season. being a QB in the nfl is tough and things can get ugly quickly. as freeman and bradford have shown you can't count on improved production/play every year.

[Camdemonium]

Anyone who thought Freeman was legit after last year deserves a kick in the shins.

[CarolinaAllDay]

Cam is #1.

Yall cant read da jerzey?? BELEEEEEEEEEEEVVVVEEEEEEEE

[Pantherball]

Cosign 100% with those saying the only QB in the NFL they would take over Killa Cam right now is Arod. Based on age, potential, current play this year.

He's special and he's ours :yesnod:

I still think Brady's the best, but Arod's been the man lately. However, I honestly don't think I would take either one of those two guys RIGHT NOW over Cam. At the start of a season....sure....they're golden.

You can still build a team around Brady or Arod and will be better off in the playoffs than you will be with Cam. But as of right now, with our O-line...I don't think either one of those guys would put up the numbers Cam does.

This O-line didn't magically improve that much. I'm almost 100% certain Cam's making it look a lot better than it is because of the respect he gets from defenses due to his size, rushing ability and the many times he's escaped to make throws on the run.

[Herb]

If Cam posted here, how much swag do you think he would have? :cam:

[smitty_89]

By the end of the year, Cam will definitely be top 5 in my opinion if he continues this pace. Right now I think he is top 10.

[panthers55]

Is he a top 10 quarterback in the league through 7 games?? Total yards it is a yes. Quarterback rating it is a no. Completion percentage it is a no.

But lets be real here. The fact that we are even having this discussion when the talking heads said it would take 2 or 3 years for him to even learn the offense is pretty miraculous. I know I said before the season started that whoever could get the ball to Smitty consistently would be my choice and obviously Newton is that guy.

Right now he is the second best quarterback in our division from a statisitical point of view. When he masters the art of the 4th quarter comeback, he will be the 2nd best Qb in the division period.

Honestly I am the most optimistic I have been about this team since 2008. Al of this nitpicking is crazy. Let other teams and their fans throw stones at the Panthers and Newton. Not us.

[BBQ&Beer]

If Cam posted here, how much swag do you think he would have? :cam:

Depends on how many sock puppets certain people would make to negswag.

[mav1234]

Honestly? Cam would probably have negative swag since he'd say he coulda played a better game, his stats don't matter, he had a chance to win at the end of the game and didn't take advantage of it, etc whenever he lost a game and some of the posters here would argue with him and take away his swag :P

Of course, when he won...

[antame]

Rodgers

Brady

Brees

(Manning)

Roth

Cam/Dalton

[ElkinPanthersFan]

What's a Schaab?

Mutual Fund... :p