After 7 games, is Cam already a.....

[Brooklyn Bully]

I have him as the 12th best QB in the league and he's only going to move on up that list as time goes on. :)

[Swarly]

why would you put Freeman in the top 10? he's got a 73 QB rating, 10 interceptions, and has been a pretty major disappointment this season. Cam is absolutely better than Freeman.

it's pretty much Brady/Rodgers/Brees in the top tier, then Cam is somewhere in that second tier, below Ben/Rivers/etc. Give it a few seasons and he could be in that top tier.

[Guest Irv]

I think everyone is getting a little ahead of themselves this question can't be truthfully answered by anyone for another 2-3 years. Were all homers here so of course hes a top 5 QB to us, it's when you start hearing cams name next to aaron rodgers and tom brady then you know he's made it.

[MaineManPanther]

Rivers is not with that to group.

Elite: Manning, Brady, Rodgers, Brees in no order

Tier 1: Roethlisberger, Romo, Vick, Cam, with Stafford and Freeman on the bubble

Then theres the Manning, Rivers, Ryan, Sanchez, Schaub, Fitzpatrick level with Dalton, Bradford, and Cassel on the bubble on down through Flacco, Smith, and Kolb group of guys that have been or could be good.

Rivers had consecutive years of 34,28,and 30 touchdowns with over 4000 yards. No way is Newton better than Rivers.

[pantherclaw]

Is this conversation, seriously happening?

A full season. A few 4th quarter come backs. A playoff performance.

All of the above will be required before i rate him with the best.

Am confident he can do these things....but the facts say he hasn't.

[ItsPantone278]

Rivers had consecutive years of 34,28,and 30 touchdowns with over 4000 yards. No way is Newton better than Rivers.

Rivers is all stats dumping balls off on screen plays getting yards in the run game and throwing it up to Gates and all those big receivers. I wouldn't trade Newton for Rivers for even one play.

[Jak3Allen]

All im talking about is starting a franchise...Manning is 35, Brady is 34, Rodgers is 27, Newton is 22 years old. Who are you going with? Better way to think of it is...starting off this year, you are the coach of the 2011 Carolina Panthers. Which qb would u rather have?

For me its Rodgers then Cam...

[Jak3Allen]

Rivers is all stats dumping balls off on screen plays getting yards in the run game and throwing it up to Gates and all those big receivers. I wouldn't trade Newton for Rivers for even one play.

Since Rivers ran the same offense Cam is running now can you take that back, cuz what is wrong with any of that?

[redbuddha]

lol

2nd in the league with ints = top 10 qb

i think cam will be a good qb, but really now....

Matt Ryan 8 Ints

Michael Vick 8 Ints

Drew Brees 8 Ints

Tom Brady 8 Ints

Cam Newton 9 Ints

Phillip Rivers 9 Ints

Josh Freeman 10 Ints

Which one is the rookie you tell me?:leaving:

[scarface]

I was talking to someone about this today.

Elite:

1. Manning

2. Rodgers

3. Brady

4. Brees

1st Tier:

5. The Rapest

6. Vick

7. Rivers

8. Homo

9. Cutler

10. Ryan

11. Cammy Cam

12. Stafford

13. Freeman

etc.

Brees, Manning and Brady are all over 32 and will be gone in a few years.

Killa Cam shall take his place among the elites with in 2-3 years.

[teeray]

I was talking to someone about this today.

Elite:

1. Manning

2. Rodgers

3. Brady

4. Brees

5. Andrew Luck

1st Tier:

5. The Rapest

6. Vick

7. Rivers

8. Homo

9. Cutler

10. Ryan

11. Cammy Cam

12. Stafford

13. Freeman

etc.

Brees, Manning and Brady are all over 32 and will be gone in a few years.

Killa Cam shall take his place among the elites with in 2-3 years.

The media told me to fix that for you.

[X-Clown]

There must be some kind of oversight, I don't see Andy Dalton on anyone's lists

/grg

[carolinarolls]

there are only a very small number of QBs I'd rather be building a team around.

This statement sums up all that matters. You can throw stats and rankings out the window.

Of course that would mean the talking heads would have to report actual news instead of what they all do now, but that is off topic and a pet peeve of mine that I will eave alone.:mad:

[hepcat]

Top 10 fantasy QB? Yes. Top 10 QB? No. Needs to win way more games first.