Hurney since 2008...

[Stumpy]

2008 Draft

Jonathon Stewart

13th overall

1 good season, under utilized, unnecessary

Currently on active roster

Jeff Otah

19th overall (traded 2009 1st round)

1 good season, injury prone, 3 of 4 seasons on IR

Currently on IR

Charles Godfrey

67th overall

Good Starter

Currently on active roster

Dan Connor

74th overall

Under utilized, unecessary, should have been traded when we had the chance

Currently on the roster

Gary Barnidge

141st overall

Never made it on the field

Currently on IR

Nick Hayden

181st overall

Complete bust

Currently out of the league

Hilee Taylor

221st overall

Never saw the field

Currently out of the league

Geoff Schwartz

241st overall

Utility backup

Currently on IR

Mackenzy Bernadeau

250th overall

Backup, looked terrible in time with starters

Currently on IR

2009 Draft

Everette Brown

43rd overall (traded 2010 1st round pick)

Complete bust

Currently out of the league

Sherrod Martin

59th overall

Decent at best starter

Currently on active roster

Corvey Irvin

93rd overall

Ineffective backup

Currently a backup for the Lions

Mike Goodson

111th overall

Decent return man, decent 3rd RB, fumbling problems

Currently inactive on gameday

Tony Fiametta

128th overall

Ineffective blocking fullback

Currently on Cowboys roster

Duke Robinson

163rd overall

Never could get in shape

Currently out of league

Captain Munnerlyn

216th overall

Good Nickelback, Bad starter

Currently on active roster

2010 Draft

Jimmy Clausen

48th overall

Terrible as a starter

Currently inactive on gameday

Brandon Lafell

78th overall

Inconsistent rookie year, looks good in limited action this year.

Currently 3rd reciever on depth chart

Armanti Edwards

89th Overall

Conversion project, ineffective on STs

Currently PR

Eric Norwood

124th overall

Tweener, not seen much time on the field.

Currently on active roster

Greg Hardy

175th overall

Playing very well, looks like an absolute steal.

Currently starting

David Gettis

198th overall

Very promising rookie year

Currently on IR

Jordan Pugh

202nd overall

Has loooked terrible in limited playing time.

Currently on active roster.

Tony Pike

204th overall

Signed BSP so he wouldn't have to see the field.

Currently out of the league

RJ Stanford

223rd overall

Yet to see the field

Currently on active roster

Robert McClain

249th overall

Looked bad in limited action

Currently inactive

I have been one of the most ardent supporters of Hurney in the (recent) past, but this is starting to get ridiculous. Many on here have voiced there displeasure with Hurney, and I have usually taken up hid defence. I have held out hope that some of these picks would come home to roost and prove that Marty knows what he is doing.

However, it has become impossible to ignore. Our last few drafts, last year excluded, (way too early) have been atrocious. The scouting change may have had something to do with it, but Hurney was the one who made those changes.

Maybe Fox had a reason to not play the young guys. Outside of Anderson, who has taken over for one the veterans that were purged that has played well in their place?

[PantherBrew]

Hmm, good thread.

There was no where else to discuss Hurney.

[4Corners]

Hmm, good thread.

There was no where else to discuss Hurney.

condescending post deserves a chop

[Dpantherman]

How many times does this thread have to get made? carry on.

[Jbro]

Been drinking beer which means I love giving neg rep.

[Stumpy]

My bad, didn't see the other thread.

But seriously, those last 3 drafts have been horseshit.

[4Corners]

Been drinking beer which means I love giving neg rep.

b/c kickball was cancelled?

[Stumpy]

.gif bomb?

[Peppers90 NC]

Hurney Thread 2nd of day:

Unnecessary, irrelevant, bad opinions, if were a player would end up cut or on IR

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Martin >>>> Godfrey.

Munnerlyn > "Bad starter"

J-Stew > One good season.

[Carl Spackler]

Stewart is very necessary

Connor is very necessary

Barnidge made the field several times

Taylor made the field several times

Too kind to AE

Stumpy fail

Nice avatar though

[DRubi15]

2011- The only pick I liked was Cam.

Past few years I've started to question Hurney. I think he's losing it. Everything about this team is changing. Lets make a change at GM also.

[Jbro]

b/c kickball was cancelled?

Correct

[Sam Mills Fan]

We can't get enough Hurney threads. The Panthers need to know that we're fed up with this clown.