Dwayne Jarret vs Legadu Naanee vs Keary Colbert vs Drew Carter

[Grammer]

Who would you trust the most to help win a football game, and why?

this is just hypothetical and for fun, don't throw a hissy fit

[OneBadassCat]

1. Drew Carter

2. Dwayne Jarrett

[mrford]

Drew Carter! he was fast as poo, and would always make those insane catches. he only had troubles when you hit him in the numbers. with Cam's weird tendency to throw high, and Carters length and speed, i kinda miss him right now.

call me crazy if you want.

[sky1597vw]

[Marguide]

Honest to all that is holy, if I had to pick a receiver to make one medium difficulty catch in a clutch situation, Naanee would be last on the list.

[Proudiddy]

TBH, Legadu has made me miss Jarrett as horrible as his time here was.

I honestly wonder if he wouldn't have had more success with this coaching staff too.

But out of this group, it would be Carter, Jarrett, Colbert, then Darvin Adams with one arm.

[Swarly]

I'm confident JR could suit up and be a more competent WR than Legedu.

Real talk.

[woody]

But but but Nanny had an amazing 30 yard catch and run...which could have been 50 or so until he decided to fall down before getting tackled. I'm not sure what his deal is. Time for LaFell to take his spot and give Armanti, Tutu, and Pilares some third receiver reps.

[Herbert The Love Bug]

But but but Nanny had an amazing 30 yard catch and run...which could have been 50 or so until he decided to fall down before getting tackled. I'm not sure what his deal is. Time for LaFell to take his spot and give Armanti, Tutu, and Pilares some third receiver reps.

This is one annoying post. It was a good catch and run and he had a nice game. Why can't you just give him that. Why do people have to be so hard on the guy. My God. I don't like him being number 2 but there is no reason to beat him up. I would like to see some other guys get chances but I don't really see LaFell being that much better than Naanee. He has made a couple flashy catches but he has made more bone head plays than good plays. At least Naanee plays smart and gives it his all. Even if it isn't that good. Maybe Rivera wants a guy to work as hard as Naanee to step up and prove he deserves the spot. We as fans probably only see about 5% at most of what all the coaches see during the week.

But I guess we are all sit at home coaches and we all know what we are talking about. Much more so than good proven NFL coaches. I mean definately.

[woody]

This is one annoying post. It was a good catch and run and he had a nice game. Why can't you just give him that. Why do people have to be so hard on the guy. My God. I don't like him being number 2 but there is no reason to beat him up. I would like to see some other guys get chances but I don't really see LaFell being that much better than Naanee. He has made a couple flashy catches but he has made more bone head plays than good plays. At least Naanee plays smart and gives it his all. Even if it isn't that good. Maybe Rivera wants a guy to work as hard as Naanee to step up and prove he deserves the spot. We as fans probably only see about 5% at most of what all the coaches see during the week.

But I guess we are all sit at home coaches and we all know what we are talking about. Much more so than good proven NFL coaches. I mean definately.

I'm not "beating him up". LaFell has outperformed him week in and week out. If you would like to see other guys get chances then that would be LaFell. He's next in line. Yes I'm aware that I am not seeing what the coaches see throughout the week but all that truly matters is game performance. It's time to see LaFell start at number 2 and give some other guys some reps at number 3.

Are you keeping count of the bone headed plays?

[Matthias]

Say what you want about Dwayne Jarrett, but when the ball was thrown his way, he made the catch.

[Cat'sGrowl]

I would take every one of those players over Naanee.

[Car123]

If Jarrett wasn't so lazy he would have been a good player. When he was on the field (which was barely) he made plays.

[jramsey4]

Say what you want about Dwayne Jarrett, but when the ball was thrown his way, he made the catch.

To be honest I think him and Cam are a perfect fit. All you had to do was get it in his vicinity and he came down with it. Of course he was slow as molasses with bad work ethic and had off the field trouble. How bad are we missing Gettis right now?