Cam Newton vs Andrew Luck - Now who would you choose?

[MWCarolina]

Neither is Luck......but that isn't stopping media from speculating that he is going to be so good that teams might be willing to sabotage this season for him...At least Cam has, so far, proven himself in the NFL...

Can't believe the guy said he would sabotage his team to get Luck...Like WTF..Isn't Luck the kid who lost every QB award to Cam while Cam was in college last season??? So Cam has to prove he belongs in the NFL because of is college years while Luck gets a free pass into the NFL because of what he's doing in college

First off, i doubt any team would really sabotage their season for Andrew Luck and whoever would is stupid. look at Washington, they have one of the worst QBs and they have won with him. NO QB is worth tanking your season. As for that guy who said it, good thing he's not a GM or coach. i am a huge Luck fan and think he will be great, but sabotaging your team for him is never a wise move. As for losing QB awards to Newton, the reason is simple, Newton had the wins and stats and that's why he beat Luck for it. as for Cam having to prove he belongs, a part of that is because of the offense, but he's showing that he can play.

[DC Amp]

Cam and the rest of the team= 1-3 and after this weekend 1-4

1-3 =? Talk to me after the season. :troll:

[x djdrew x]

if Luck didn't want to come to Carolina, fine. Let him rot on the Bengals or some team like that.

I would take Cam 100/100 times. Luck might come in and not live up to the hype....then you know what they will say? "That Andrew Luck is alright but he sure isn't CAM NEWTON."

feels good typing that

[4Corners]

[Porn Shop Clerk]

OMG WHAT IF SANTA CLAUSE WAS REAL?

AND HE HAD SEX WITH THE EASTER BUNNY?

WOULD THEIR BABY BE THE TOOTH FAIRY?

lolol

[footballisasport]

I said Cam, but I think it's too early. Both could be hall of famers though, just in my honest opinion you guys are making it sound like Cam is on a whole different level than Luck when that's a ridiculous statement.

What I find is how Luck is to end up in the HOF and he hasn't even stepped foot on the NFL field, while Cam gets a "it's to early" to tell...Seriously, do u guys really give thought to what you are posting???

[YoungPanthers89]

[King Taharqa]

Newton was and is the better QB. More dynamic, more potential, and more of a winner. Luck was just more marketable to the fans that hated and didnt believe in QBs like Cam. The pressure and hype Luck is now gonna be forced to live up to I wouldnt wish on any kid. His myth is now a huge burden.

[4Corners]

I dunno about this whole more potential thing, KT, but everything happens for a reason. I'm delighted about Cam and I doubt that Luck will end up being a bust. Especially if he has a chance to learn from Peyton Manning.

[King Taharqa]

No way the Colts keep Manning and draft Luck. Too much $$$ tied up in the QB position. Luck will go to a team where he will have to be the man from day one.

[o_O]

Newton was and is the better QB. More dynamic, more potential, and more of a winner. Luck was just more marketable to the fans that hated and didnt believe in QBs like Cam. The pressure and hype Luck is now gonna be forced to live up to I wouldnt wish on any kid. His myth is now a huge burden.

I swear, as much as you talk up Cam we should be 4-0 & headed to a 19-0 Super Bowl Champion finish.

Cam Newton is playing very well. He could go on to have a HOF career, but he very well could bust. Nobody knows. Same with Andrew Luck. There has never been a can't miss sure thing in any sport & never will be.

[hank pimple butt]

haven't seen Luck throw for 400+ plus yards against a pro defense.Cam is just unbelievable talent! I don't think Luck can extend plays or avoid pressure like Cam.

Cam hands down!

btw, the most important thing is.....Cam wants to be a Panther. Luck went to school another year to avoid that fate.

[frash.exe]

I swear, as much as you talk up Cam we should be 4-0 & headed to a 19-0 Super Bowl Champion finish.

Cam Newton is playing very well. He could go on to have a HOF career, but he very well could bust. Nobody knows. Same with Andrew Luck. There has never been a can't miss sure thing in any sport & never will be.

lol i think the picture is becoming clearer and clearer which direction Cam's career is headed every week

his presence on the offense is the only reason we haven't lost a game by more than 1 score

[King Taharqa]

I swear, as much as you talk up Cam we should be 4-0 & headed to a 19-0 Super Bowl Champion finish.

Cam Newton is playing very well. He could go on to have a HOF career, but he very well could bust. Nobody knows. Same with Andrew Luck. There has never been a can't miss sure thing in any sport & never will be.

As much as you guys hyped up Luck youd think he won a Heisman or led his team to a title. This spring it was all but certain Luck was the better prospect, now its he could be. Lol. Luck is gonna have a tough time living up to the hype of "clearly being better than Cam". Dude might just say fug it and become an architect.