Cam Newton vs Andrew Luck - Now who would you choose?

[rayzor]

[ctrcat]

After our :cam: SHATTERED Peyton Manning's passing yard mark for a player in his first game, it hit me more than ever-Andrew Luck wanted to play against Duke without his head coach that weekend instead of playing in the National Football League's opening weekend. Our guy is bigger, stronger, faster, won the Heisman and National Title, is smashing NFL rooke passing records, has "it", and wants to be playing in the NFL and for us.

Thank God for unanswered prayers, and for Andrew Luck staying in school!!!!!!!

[blackcatgrowl]

Andrew Luck's name should never be spoken b/c he is now irrelevent.

:yesnod:

:cam:

[Cyclonus]

We need a filter for the words Andrew Luck!

[GritsRgreat]

Panthers would be 4 - 0 with Luck.

[rayzor]

still some voting for luck. smh.

this is a poll that needed to keep track of who voted.

[Jangler]

where is the dildo choice?

[CarolinaCatBrigade]

i said all along last year that luck was my first choice and newton was easily my second regardless of where we picked. i thought that luck would be ahead of newton, but over all not by much.

i'm glad luck stayed in because i think that newton will end up being more dynamic, though both players will be at the top of their game. i just hope luck goes to the AFC. i would love to see those two face each other in the superbowl.

newton was the right pick. no way would i go back and change that. no way do i wish we had been able to draft luck instead. we got the right one.

I specifically recall you were on the PP7 bandwagon quite a bit. So easily 2nd choice? hmmm ;) Just kidding. I was skeptical for a while, I was on the Darius bandwagon, but once Cam got drafted I jumped up and down and screamed like a little girl. :party:

[Udogg]

Panthers would be 4 - 0 with Luck.

You're trying too hard but keep up the good fight :p

[YoungPanthers89]

Panthers would be 4 - 0 with Luck.

shhhhcclclllurrrppppp

[Grammer]

Panthers would be 4 - 0 with Luck.

you're stepping very close to troll territory

dont become TRD with a hot sig/avatar

[Captain Obvious]

i chose luck because of his skin color please recognize the sarcasm

[smitty_89]

Luck's decision to not leave college was the turning point of the Panthers organization! Thank you Mr. Luck.

[Tarheels23]

What did they say on PTI? I'm sure Wilbon said Cam...

It's crazy that they had the same topic today!