Cam Newton vs Andrew Luck - Now who would you choose?

[maddog]

It's just my opinion that they are going to hype the crap out of luck and he will not turn out to be the quarterback that Cam is developing into. After watching Luck face Duke, I'm glad we got a QB with more than just an ability to throw a football.

[CardiacCats]

I said Cam, but I think it's too early. Both could be hall of famers though, just in my honest opinion you guys are making it sound like Cam is on a whole different level than Luck when that's a ridiculous statement.

[GritsRgreat]

I'd bet money it was Grits.

:cool:

[teeray]

I like Luck as a pro prospect but the hype machine on him right now is at ridiculous proportions. He is not the greatest prospect in 25 years and blah, blah, blah.

He is good but he has several things to work on and I am not sure he is a better pro prospect than Palmer was, or Peyton Manning was, or Vick was, or Bradford was, and I never thought he was light years ahead of Cam either.

There is a part of me that is hoping that Luck is a spectacular bust and every time I hear someone gush about how he is the greatest prospect in 25 years that desire to see him fail grows more and more.

[teeray]

At this point, my only thought regarding Luck is that if he is as good as advertised, I'd much rather he wind up in the AFC.

He's not.

[Herbert The Love Bug]

Wow, right when I was reading through this thread PTI asked this same Question. Who would you rather have Cam or Luck. Weird.

Anyways, unlike some people on here I am going to be honest about it. I definately wanted Luck way more than Cam at the time. Cam wasn't even on my mind. Luck was all I could think about and I was so upset when he decided to stay in school. I didn't want to have to settle for Cam. But WOW I am not sure I would want anyone over Cam Newton now. We are so lucky to have him. It was a huge risk taking a guy with only one year of major college experience. I don't include his time at Florida.

but yeah I am so happy to have Cam and would want anybody else. Not Luck, not Rogers, not even Brady. Cam is my man!

[GritsRgreat]

He's not.

Yeah i think the Vikings will draft him. Them or Seattle.

[CardiacCats]

What did they say on PTI? I'm sure Wilbon said Cam...

[X-Clown]

:cool:

Shouldn't you be Pieing Camdemonium's every post?

[GritsRgreat]

Shouldn't you be Pieing Camdemonium's every post?

No, never heard of him.

[Jangler]

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Shut the f*ck up, but Cam for what it's worth.

[Ivan The Awesome]

I'm still trying to figure out what the point/purpose/need for this thread is...

[Shotgun]

F*ck Luck