Would have Rivera taken Vick?

[Jrock88]

Vick was and still is a dynamic football player. Some might even say hes an entertainer, but hes no ICON.

:cam:

[bleys]

Vick would NOT have been valuable to this Franchise..

[footballisasport]

Vick was and still is a dynamic football player. Some might even say hes an entertainer, but hes no ICON.

:cam:

Not yet at least...But Cam is already an Icon in his college, like it or not.:D

[CarolinaNCSU]

Sign him then or not, I'm glad we didn't. We have a kid in Cam who can one day be a better passer than Vick ever dreamed about, while still having some of the running ability without being made of porcelain. Highly doubt Vick would've done anything in our system last year anyway.

[Herbert The Love Bug]

I don't like Vick and Rivera and myself usually agree on things so I am saying no.

[jks85]

Don't know, but Richardson and Hurney have the final call and they wouldn't.

this

[Udogg]

Anyone who has been here for any length of time know what direction this thread is going to go. I don't think it should even be allowed in "Carolina Panthers" forum. There Should be a what if forum so everyone there can debate why or why not MV would have worked here. If it stays here its going to be the usual class warfare, crime or no crime, racist or not type of post that were basically exhausted and rehashed to death in all the other Micheal Vick threads.

[CarolinaPanthersFan#1]

Michael Vick's problem this year is his OLINE. With all those big money deals with players at other positions, it looks like the Eagles didn't find quality guys for Vick's Oline. Vick is probably going to be sitting on the sidelines injured this season before long. Gotta have a couple of Pro Bowlers in the trenches in order to make the QB and backs look good.

[mav1234]

<insert race baiting>

<insert images of abused dogs>

Back to the topic at hand - wouldn't have mattered if Rivera had because JR/Hurney wouldn't have.

[jim stone]

Maybe at San Deigo, but he came to Carolina. No Vick cry baby at the Panthers.

[TerriblePizza]

Vick has been doing so well as a passer because Andy Reid is an offensive genius. Look how good he made McNabb look for all those years.

I think Cam is a more natural passer than Vick.

Vick = Run first, pass later

[bleys]

Vick has been doing so well as a passer because Andy Reid is an offensive genius. Look how good he made McNabb look for all those years.

I think Cam is a more natural passer than Vick.

Vick = Run first, pass later

McNabb just got old.. I fail to understand how someone thinks McNabb never had skills, it was Andy Reid playing QB out there...