Cam Up For Rookie of the Week Round 3

[Wyank]

http://www.nfl.com/voting/rookies

Not sure if he deserves it this week though.

Torrey Smith

152 yards receiving 3 TDs would be my non-homer pick.

[Nicbsbll2]

Cam's going to set another record: Most times nominated for ROTW without winning.

[Kettle]

3/3 on a game winning drive makes me want to vote for him. Smith had a hell of a showing though. Only other one I'd vote for would be the lineman. Kickers, cowboys and falcons don't get my votes.

[GritsRgreat]

Voted Smith couldn't help it.

But i'll bet the kicker from Dallas wins. Huge fan base.

[smitty_89]

T. Smith deserves this one.

[TruCatzFan]

This is a no brainer. Torrey Smith.

Kicker from Dallas didn't kick any long/clutch field goals IMO

Torrey Smith, first 3 catches in NFL career all TD's.

[Panthro]

Voted Smith couldn't help it.

But i'll bet the kicker from Dallas wins. Huge fan base.

1st week ...Cam sets records but didn't help his team win. You vote for Cobb for that reason.

Cam throws for even more yards against the Super Bowl champs but still lost the game. You voted for some defensive player.

Newton finally wins a game and you vote for Smith.

[GritsRgreat]

Yeah Smith had the better outing and his team won.

[Wyank]

1st week ...Cam sets records but didn't help his team win. You vote for Cobb for that reason.

Cam throws for even more yards against the Super Bowl champs but still lost the game. You voted for some defensive player.

Newton finally wins a game and you vote for Smith.

I don't blame him this week for voting for Smith.

[caatfan]

Must have been a ho hum day all around for him to even get nominated. I don't see any way he wins this week.

[Sloth]

Newton deserved it the first two weeks.

This week he's just filler. Smith should absolutely get it.

[Panthro]

I don't blame him this week for voting for Smith.

I don't either but based on his prior voting criteria Cam Newton should've won his vote

[liljah8303]

Cam will be nominated every week for the simple fact that he is Cam.

[rodeo]

Cam's going to set another record: Most times nominated for ROTW without winning.

But that sets him up as a shoe-in for ROTY. He'll have the most nominations, and even if some random individual has a fluke game that is better that week, there won't be anyone displaying Cam's consistency over the season.