Matt Ryan Vs Jay Cutler, who'd you want as your QB?

[jtnc]

I say Cutler, better arm, makes some unbelievable throws. Ryan's success is a large part of his offensive weapons such as Turner, White and Julio and a pretty good offensive line.

[PntherPryd]

Ryan. For all his warts, he's a fighter. Not everything is stats.

I could never root for Jay Cutler and I pray to God Hurney or Hurney's replacement never puts that to the test.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Cutler has never had a 2-1 INT ratio in his career. Ryans is almost 2-1 for his career.

[SteveSmithTD89]

Cam Newton

[Grammer]

Captain Checkdown vs Rex Grossman 2.0

let me get back to you on that

[jtnc]

Cutler has had great success with what he has on as far as offensive weapons.

[Saint J]

Cutler is actually talented

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Cutler is actually talented

Ryans QB rating vs the Saints is 93. Just saying.

[Kevin Greene]

Cutler is actually talented

And an emo whiney bitch no Franchise should want leading their team come game day.

[jtnc]

And an emo whiney bitch no Franchise should want leading their team come game day.

His teammates have no problem with him, so what? Public perception doesn't mean poo. If jis teammates respect him.

[Boltergeist]

And an emo whiney bitch no Franchise should want leading their team come game day.

you just had to say the magic word

[Mr. Scot]

This reminds me of the old "death by hunga bunga" joke.

Both have their pros and cons, but having those two as my only choices wouldn't exactly make me a happy camper.

[JawnyBlaze]

Yea, I wouldn't prefer either but if I had to choose I'd take Ryan, he seems to be a better leader.

[panthers55]

I am with Mr Scot I would take Newton over either of them. It is like asking if you would rather get punched in the balls or kicked. The obviously answer is neither.

If we could get them free then either would make a good backup. But Ryan cost too much and cutler cost too much in draft picks for average results. Newton was cheaper and in the end will be better.