Andrew luck to colts?

[blackcatgrowl]

Collins Played in the Superbowl and even led the Panthers to the playoffs... i don't even know if Garrard ever made the playoffs.

Well, that explains part of it.

You need to bone up on your info before you make statements like X player > Y player.

Garrard took the Jags to the playoffs being in the same Division as the Peyton Manning Colts in 2007.

He's no slouch. Go read up on him. Had be been on a better team in a weaker division, he would have had a much more rewarding career to this point.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Garrard#Jacksonville_Jaguars

[Jackofalltrades]

I'd take Garrard over Collins any day and the Jags really fugged him with such a late release.

I really wish they wouldn't let players just come out retirement any time they want.

[o_O]

I'd take Garrard over Collins any day and the Jags really fugged him with such a late release.

I really wish they wouldn't let players just come out retirement any time they want.

No way. Kerry Collins is probably the most under-appreciated player in the league. He is a good QB.

[Jackofalltrades]

No way. Kerry Collins is probably the most under-appreciated player in the league. He is a good QB.

From Blackcatgrowl I give you this:

Garrard is better in every statistical category. He's more accurate. He's more mobile. Garrard tied the record for fewest interceptions in a year (only 3) in 2007 and helped the Jaguars to an 11-5 record. If that team was in a number of other divisions in the NFC or AFC they would have been to the playoffs several years while he was leading them.

Links to stats are listed in his post as well.

[HoFBound90]

If it does happen somehow it sounds like a giant conspiracy the nfl implemented years ago that is finally unfolding. Sure you lost the best qb of this generation so here is the next potential great one.

[GritsRgreat]

Hmmm if Garrard is so great, why isn't most NFL teams knocking down the door to sign him?

[transitCATS]

If the Colts had signed Jake Delhomme THEN I would say they were entering the Luck sweepstakes!

I hear they considered him too.

[Dpantherman]

Hmmm if Garrard is so great, why isn't most NFL teams knocking down the door to sign him?

For starters, the season begins tomorrow.

[Tarheels23]

The all mighty one just threw a Pick 6 to Duke.

[Hawk]

hawks will win some games... NFCW is pathetic

but...according to the huddle...the saints suck, the bucs suck, the falcons suck and you've got to unproven qb's and an aging wr star...and that makes the NFCS much better?

[GritsRgreat]

The all mighty one just threw a Pick 6 to Duke.

Off a receivers hands, also thrown two TDs

[Dpantherman]

but...according to the huddle...the saints suck, the bucs suck, the falcons suck and you've got to unproven qb's and an aging wr star...and that makes the NFCS much better?

The Huddle is on acid, you know this.

[Grammer]

but...according to dumbasses...the saints suck, the bucs suck, the falcons suck and you've got to unproven qb's and an aging wr star...and that makes the NFCS much better?

fixed

and that pick six was not lucks fault, i saw it

[Hawk]

oh no...I explicity trust the knowledge level of the huddlers...so if they say those teams suck, they must really suck