I hate thinking this way..but..

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

It's not so much that he wanted out; as much as he wanted to practically commit robbery against the Panthers with his proposed contract.

[Gipetto]

[pantherclaw]

Marshall was our 3rd best corner.

He was overrated by our own fans since his first season.

Having him back wouldn't improve our starting cbs.

[jtnc]

He never wanted out, he wanted a longer contract, he was annoyed with getting an RFA tender placed on him.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Marshall was one of the worst starting CBs in the league last year. We should have signed someone to replace him but letting him go was smart.

[jtnc]

Marshall was one of the worst starting CBs in the league last year. We should have signed someone to replace him but letting him go was smart.

But could you blame him? That whole fuging backfield was horrible.

[jtnc]

From Marshall's twitter after he signed with the Cardinals

TheMarshall31 Richard Marshall

I will always love my fans in Carolina I had great memories there. The fans and the organization was great to me .

[brandon_87]

Little late now. Either we, or he, will get the last laugh on Sept. 11.

Have a feeling, win or lose,we will, I think he will catch a stewie stiffy, and maybe get to get run over by cam.

[Chaos]

Another second round pick gone...put him on the list.

[pantherclaw]

Another second round pick gone...put him on the list.

what list?

He was a good pick, and played well for us until we asked to mmuch of him.

So what list are you speaking of? I'm curious.

[Chaos]

what list?

He was a good pick, and played well for us until we asked to mmuch of him.

So what list are you speaking of? I'm curious.

The list of second round picks this team has made that haven't panned out for whichever reason, either they underwhelmed, had injury issues, or had some value and left for nothing in return (Marshall). Back to 2003, omitting only Kalil and Sherrod Martin as they provide a significant contribution:

Jimmy Clausen

Everette Brown

Dwayne Jarrett

Richard Marshall

Eric Shelton

Keary Colbert

Bruce Nelson

That's one hell of a list there.

[Gipetto]

Jimmy clausen - could end up being a quality backup

everette brown - It took charles johnson a couple years to get it the jury is still otu on him

dwayne jarrett - just an idiot that wasted his talent

Richard Marshall - we asked too much of him

Eric Shelton An idiot as well

Keary Colbert - Went mambo #5 on us

bruce nelson - not his fault he just couldn't put his hips into it.

[pantherclaw]

The list of second round picks this team has made that haven't panned out for whichever reason, either they underwhelmed, had injury issues, or had some value and left for nothing in return (Marshall). Back to 2003, omitting only Kalil and Sherrod Martin as they provide a significant contribution:

Jimmy Clausen

Everette Brown

Dwayne Jarrett

Richard Marshall

Eric Shelton

Keary Colbert

Bruce Nelson

That's one hell of a list there.

undervalue...he performed well as a nickle back, which is what he projected to be. He made an impact his rookie season. He rarely missed time for injury. So he lived up to the value of his pick, and contract.

As for the "we let him walk and got no value for him"

That's the nfl. No team in the league goes around trading away their players just cause they are coming to the end of their contract. I don't know what world you live in, but it's not reality.

[pantherj]

Will we recieve a compensatory draft pick for Marshall?