Rank the following QB performances over 3 weeks from best to worst

[TheRealDeal]

I did assume. History shows most teams take the 3rd game the most serious and it's as close to a real game as you will get.

I also included total numbers for your comparison.

[frash.exe]

but the problem is you probably know i saw the same stats before i posted it, therefore I do not care. I knew you were going to make this point anyway.

the point is this completion percentage thing that people keep emphasizing is quite common when it comes to rookie QBs, they have games like this. plus there have been no OTAs. For the most part they don't finish in the 40s as far as completion percentage goes but they do look bad in some of their first performances. This is based in fact.

[TheRealDeal]

Of course they do, but they also have games over 50.

They don't average 40. They might have a bad game or two, but when they average a bad games in terms of other rookies, it's a problem.

[tight lines]

Ryan has done no such thing...nor has Flacco. Vick has taken a team to the NFCCG and Eli has a ring, yet you have Ryan and Flacco, neither of whom have done anything as better?

Laughable at best and I hate both Vick and Eli.

Im comparing Quarterbacks not teams. Ryan and Flacco have put up 3 consecutive solid seasons each. Ring or not based on how each quarterback has performed, Id take Flacco or Ryan over Vick or Eli Any day of the week and twice on Sunday.

On another note if Vick follows up his last season with something respectable his status would change in my eyes.

[Happy Panther]

Remember when we did this last year?

Like Aikman had a terrible rookie year but then became a hall of famer and that's why Clausen doesn't suck?

[TheRealDeal]

:lol:

[Sam Mills Fan]

Remember when we did this last year?

Like Aikman had a terrible rookie year but then became a hall of famer and that's why Clausen doesn't suck?

Big difference between preseason and regular season kiddo.

If Newton continues to struggle at the end of the season, have at it. But saying he sucks because of his preseason play? That's fan dumbassery.