Rank the following QB performances over 3 weeks from best to worst

[Sam Mills Fan]

Okay, it was more of a list of quarterbacks that are at least good that came from the 1st round. The only one I can think of that I left off was Roethlisberger looking at it; I might dig his info up and post it later.

[tight lines]

Okay, it was more of a list of quarterbacks that are at least good that came from the 1st round. The only one I can think of that I left off was Roethlisberger looking at it; I might dig his info up and post it later.

Good Ill buy.

[TheRealDeal]

Sam Bradford killin it.

Solid rookie season and getting better on top of that.

That's what #1 picks do ladies and gentlemen.

[Ivan The Awesome]

You forgot L and M.

L. 17 of 29 for 173 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT. 0 Rush TD.

M. 3 of 4 for 71 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT. 0 Rush TD.

What's your point again?

Oh by the way, L is Jimmy, M is Anderson.

[mercules20]

Sam Bradford killin it.

Solid rookie season and getting better on top of that.

That's what #1 picks do ladies and gentlemen.

successful ones

[footballisasport]

As good as Sam was/is, he wasn't that perfect. He actually got an interception in the Pariots game and one more in another game during his preseason. I remembere, plus the info is on the internet.

[Jackofalltrades]

Someone needs to show this to Michael Procton, he got so bad I had to unfollow him on twitter.

[Jackofalltrades]

1.Cam Newton,Michael Vick,Sam Bradford,Josh Freeman,Matthew Stafford,Mark Sanchez, and Eli Manning dont belong on an list of Great quarterbacks at this time. Some of them may end up on one at some point in time.

2 Matt Ryan, Joe Flacco, Phillip Rivers, and Aaron Rodgers have at least earned the right for greatness to be discussed.

3 3 preseason games worth of stats is nowhere near enough to make any kind of sane judgement about how a qb is going to do.

4 Cam Newton based on his performance to date is not ready to start. That does not mean I dont't think he will be a good qb.

Ryan has done no such thing...nor has Flacco. Vick has taken a team to the NFCCG and Eli has a ring, yet you have Ryan and Flacco, neither of whom have done anything as better?

Laughable at best and I hate both Vick and Eli.

[chef17]

As good as Sam was/is, he wasn't that perfect. He actually got an interception in the Pariots game and one more in another game during his preseason. I remembere, plus the info is on the internet.

No one expects any QB to be perfect. You really should let that go

[frash.exe]

Sam Bradford killin it.

Solid rookie season and getting better on top of that.

That's what #1 picks do ladies and gentlemen.

Bradford also had sub 50% completion percentage performances in preseason games his first season

[Marguide]

1.Cam Newton,Michael Vick,Sam Bradford,Josh Freeman,Matthew Stafford,Mark Sanchez, and Eli Manning dont belong on an list of Great quarterbacks at this time.

The Eagles apparently disagree in regard to Vick, as they just gave him a 6 year, 100 million dollar contract, with 36 of it guaranteed.

[Sam Mills Fan]

If Sam Bradford had those stats, they must have come in his final preseason game. Read carefully, I only included the first 3 preseason games for the QBs in question. The source are the historic box scores from nfl.com.

[TheRealDeal]

Bradford also had sub 50% completion percentage performances in preseason games his first season

Game 3: With gameplanning:

15/22 68% 8.6ypa 189 yds 2 TD 0 Int

Overall preseason:

33/55 60% 6.1ypa 338yds 3 TD 0 Int

Move along please.

[frash.exe]

Game 3: With gameplanning:

15/22 68% 8.6ypa 189 yds 2 TD 0 Int

Overall preseason:

33/55 60% 6.1ypa 338yds 3 TD 0 Int

Move along please.

and the argument changes

how do you know how much they "gameplanned"? did you assume because it was week 3?