A QB Comparison

[TheRealDeal]

Predicting his failure is not the same as saying he has reached that failure.

More reading comprehension...

You also told me his footwork was perfect so your 99%means nothing to me

[blackcatgrowl]

Predicting his failure is not the same as saying he has reached that failure.

More reading comprehension...

You also told me his footwork was perfect so your 99%means nothing to me

See... you admit you've said he'll be a bust. You've posted non-stop since the start of preseason how terrible his throws have been. You're making a case against the guy using preseason play as a criteria to prove your point.

You can try and spin this all day chump, but when you boil off the pile of stinking crap that constitues your posting, all you're trying to say is "Look, look, he sucks, see, he's a bust in progress!!!"

Where you fail, is the fact this is preseason play from a rookie.

[Carl Spackler]

LOLfans

[footballisasport]

Seriously, are you a ratard or just a Newton family member?

Family member NO...Also if ur going to insult me, please SPELLCHECK...it takes away from ur agenda..:hand:

[TheRealDeal]

You thinking ratard is misspelled shows you are in fact a ratard.

[footballisasport]

Predicting his failure is not the same as saying he has reached that failure.

More reading comprehension...

You also told me his footwork was perfect so your 99%means nothing to me

And u have concluded that in five weeks of training, including three pregames. Good to know.

[TheRealDeal]

See... you admit you've said he'll be a bust. You've posted non-stop since the start of preseason how terrible his throws have been. You're making a case against the guy using preseason play as a criteria to prove your point.

You can try and spin this all day chump, but when you boil off the pile of stinking crap that constitues your posting, all you're trying to say is "Look, look, he sucks, see, he's a bust in progress!!!"

Where you fail, is the fact this is preseason play from a rookie.

What I think will happen in the future, the opinion that hadn't changed since pre draft, has no bearing on this discussion.

Apologists have claimed people have already said he's a bust. Show me where I or others have or STFU

[TheRealDeal]

And u have concluded that in five weeks of training, including three pregames. Good to know.

Read the whole sentence :lol:

New breed of Panther fans, enjoy becoming Falconslife

[blackcatgrowl]

What I think will happen in the future, the opinion that hadn't changed since pre draft, has no bearing on this discussion.

Apologists have claimed people have already said he's a bust. Show me where I or others have or STFU

Since searching is disabled on the Huddle, I can't readily show you anything anyone has said about him here.

But, since you're adamant "No one is saying this", here ya go.

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Cam+Newton+proving+he+is+a+bust

Comment after comment on board after board bashing him... kinda like you do.

And since you won't man up to what you're doing on this board, you're kindly welcome to have a nice warm glass of shut the hell up yourself chump.

P.S. I've never said Newton's footwork was "perfect". I might have said it "looked perfect" in certain plays, which it has. You're a liar.

[TheRealDeal]

False, you said he had zero issues with footwork

[mav1234]

Gee, like who are they? The same folks who made it clear that they were going to overscrutinize Cam. I will take anything they say about Cam with a grain of salt.

How is that saying "Cam is a bust"? If anything, that's being overcritical of him, but I don't think Cam is a bust and I don't think the vast majority of other posters here think so either. I don't even know for sure if anyone does.

"Holding our team back" is the same thing as saying "He'll be a bust."

No, it means "I think we may have been a better team if we had gone in this other direction", which I apply to all the rookie QBs out there, and I certainly don't think any of them are busts.

edit: BCG that link shows a ton of bleacher report articles. Are you saying that posters here are posting those?

[blackcatgrowl]

False, you said he had zero issues with footwork

"Zero issues" doesn't mean "perfect". It means there isn't anything so wrong with it that he can't adjust to play in the NFL.

Also, I actually DID admit there might be some footwork issues early on.

Now who's failing the reading comprehension tests?

[mav1234]

you definitely said Cam did not have a problem with footwork, when it's pretty clear he does...

[blackcatgrowl]

How is that saying "Cam is a bust"? If anything, that's being overcritical of him, but I don't think Cam is a bust and I don't think the vast majority of other posters here think so either. I don't even know for sure if anyone does.

No, it means "I think we may have been a better team if we had gone in this other direction", which I apply to all the rookie QBs out there, and I certainly don't think any of them are busts.

Mav, seriously... TRD doesn't need your help. I'd shy away from interpreting what he says. We all know how he feels about Cam, even if he won't admit to it. ;)

edit: BCG that link shows a ton of bleacher report articles. Are you saying that posters here are posting those?

Not at all. I'm saying there are people already claiming he's a bust. And yes, there have been people here who predicted he would be, and are trying to prove it with every errant throw, and every mis-step in preseason games.