Would you be upset if we traded J-Stew?

[thefuzz]

Yes, very.

We should have let Dwill walk, and gone after JJ instead. We would still have a solid backfield, and wouldn't have just given an aging back top end money.

[Gipetto]

If you can do it in madden you can do it in the nfl. Remember "It's in the game"

DERP

[mj4life]

until we see how chud plans to use both, why not keep them. i could see stew being like a h-back in this offense. we know he runs well but he's is a decent blocker & can catch out of the backfield

[Varking]

Can Goodson or Sutton help compensate the loss of Stew? If so, then trade him. Running backs are a dime a dozen in this league. But you need to have an offer worthy of a trade.

[scarface]

I'd rather trade OP.

[DRSundrop]

i dont want jstew to leave but you cant say no to any possible ridiculously tasty offer either.

[Carolina Crazy V2]

What are the chances we will be able to lock up J-Stew long term? It is likely because we locked up DeAngelo, J-Stew will eventually be playing for another team. (The only way I see these guys staying together is if J-Stew just want to stay here versus being paid as a number one guy) So would any of you be upset if we traded him to get a quality starter at cornerback and some draft picks?

Yes shitface.

[bleys]

I love to read some of y'alls logic..

DWill is practically god's son, who actually misses games due to injuries, but Stew can't take on a full load because he's injury prone despite missing 2 games in 3 seasons..

some of you are really fuging stupid.. :lol:

if we traded JStew, we would be left with Goodson on the field most of the time when DWill is carted off.. how's that improve our team?

[bleys]

Yes, very.

We should have let Dwill walk, and gone after JJ instead. We would still have a solid backfield, and wouldn't have just given an aging back top end money.

truth.. for those stil living in denial, it'll become more evident.. it's nice to have DWill on the team, he's a beast.. however, there are certain positions you spend cap space on and those you ALWAYS rebuild through the draft..

RB is one of those.. however, since we did spend the money, hopefully (as Panthro mentioned) we'll be able to restructure his deal in 2 years..

he's a smart cat, I think he'll go for it.. we'll end up paying Stew about the same as DWill...

[Davidson Deac II]

I love to read some of y'alls logic..

DWill is practically god's son, who actually misses games due to injuries, but Stew can't take on a full load because he's injury prone despite missing 2 games in 3 seasons..

some of you are really fuging stupid.. :lol:

if we traded JStew, we would be left with Goodson on the field most of the time when DWill is carted off.. how's that improve our team?

Unless we trade Stewart for a high draft pick, and use that pick to get another running back. :)

But unless someone makes a ridiculous offer for Stewart, no we should not trade him.

[bleys]

Unless we trade Stewart for a high draft pick, and use that pick to get another running back. :)

But unless someone makes a ridiculous offer for Stewart, no we should not trade him.

agreed, considering there's no way in hell that happens though.. we should keep Stew.

my point is if we were going to trade anyone, it would be the older fella who just received a big contract and actually misses games..

maybe in 2 years, we can trade DWill and receive some value.. that is the goal people should put in the forefront of their mind.. receive value before you release non-value..

we aren't marrying these players, if you want success, you replenish your roster with youth (which requires coaching)

[Zorbac]

quote:

Originally Posted by Matthias

What are the chances we will be able to lock up J-Stew long term? It is likely because we locked up DeAngelo, J-Stew will eventually be playing for another team. (The only way I see these guys staying together is if J-Stew just want to stay here versus being paid as a number one guy) So would any of you be upset if we traded him to get a quality starter at cornerback and some draft picks?

Just hold off til next year to make a decision on J-Stew.

How about instead of trading J-Stew. We trade Goodson for veteran DT Corey Williams(Detroit Lions) and a mid to late round pick. Lets say a 5th- 6th. They are in dire straits for a quality RB w/ their top running going down with an torn achilies. It leaves them with only 1 quality running back left.

This would fill our need for a veteran DT, and give Detroit the RB they need. A win/win situation. Back-up RB = Vet DT & draft pick.

This is from excerpts from an article by: AUTHOR: Seth McConnell at Cat Crave Titled: "To Bulk Up the Defensive Line, Detroit’s Corey Williams Would Make Sense. Plus a couple of my own thoughts.

[nosuchthingasapanther]

quote:

Just hold off til next year to make a decision on J-Stew.

How about instead of trading J-Stew. We trade Goodson for veteran DT Corey Williams(Detroit Lions) and a mid to late round pick. Lets say a 5th- 6th. They are in dire straits for a quality RB w/ their top running going down with an torn achilies. It leaves them with only 1 quality running back left.

This would fill our need for a veteran DT, and give Detroit the RB they need. A win/win situation. Back-up RB = Vet DT & draft pick.

This is from excerpts from an article by: AUTHOR: Seth McConnell at Cat Crave Titled: "To Bulk Up the Defensive Line, Detroit’s Corey Williams Would Make Sense. Plus a couple of my own thoughts.

some of you really think goodson has trade value?

wow.

an rb who can't hold onto the ball is like that retarded bird on Rio who couldn't fly.

nobody is going to trade for a 3rd string rb with a bad case of fumblitis.

nobody.

[Zorbac]

If a team is desperate enough...

Everybody has trade value.