Panthers Ratings for Madden 12

[adub2b23]

I'd say it's pretty accurate except for Khalil 86, who should be at least 90. While Wharton is a solid guard, Khalil should not be only 1 point higher than him. Also I believe Stewart should be a few points higher than 81. Wharton and Khalil both being rate I would have liked to see Munnerlyn and Pilares get some more love.

[Clicheking]

Very fair. Kalil and Stew should of been higher is my only comment.

[CRA]

Either way I can work with his ratings.

I wonder what I'll get in a trade for Newton....

that is the defintion of being a hater.

Cam is clearly the future for your team.

On top of that, his ratings simply translate to being a better video game QB than Clausen....he clearly has the edge as Madden QB.

......yet you want to trade him.

[HoFBound90]

Either way I can work with his ratings.

I wonder what I'll get in a trade for Newton....

And this is why most madden players are not football smart.

[SCMunnerlyn1]

To be fair .. i'll be trading Newton also. I prefer a pocket passer on my team , not sure what i'll trade him for as of yet , but it will probably be 1 to 2 years down the road. I do fairly well on madden. As I think about it , 2 years from now .. Offensive line will be disasterdly (not sure if thats a word) bad so I may look for help there.

[Carl Spackler]

that is the defintion of being a hater.

Cam is clearly the future for your team.

On top of that, his ratings simply translate to being a better video game QB than Clausen....he clearly has the edge as Madden QB.

......yet you want to trade him.

Well, let's be fair, you've always been a pretty stellar Clausen hater. I wouldn't trade either but that's just me.

[HoFBound90]

We finally get a player to have some fun with in Madden and people want to trade him already...if this isn't indicative of the attitudes on the huddle. To each his own, at least try hi out in some exhbition games.

[Carl Spackler]

Well I make the depth chart exactly as the team has it for any particular week so if Newton isn't starting in real life he isn't starting on the game.

[The_Cannon]

To be fair .. i'll be trading Newton also. I prefer a pocket passer on my team , not sure what i'll trade him for as of yet , but it will probably be 1 to 2 years down the road. I do fairly well on madden. As I think about it , 2 years from now .. Offensive line will be disasterdly (not sure if thats a word) bad so I may look for help there.

If you go by those rating Cam is a better pocket QB than Clausen. He's only going to scramble, if you make him scramble. Cam's stats beat Clausens in every passing category (Throw power, throw accuracy, Short ball and deep ball) only categories that Clausen beats him in is Play action and medium ball by two points.

[CarolinaKid704]

I'll make them all play like 99 overall.

Official SWAG of the Carolina Panthers.

[OneBadassCat]

Wow they low balled the poo out of Stewart. 89 for Smith is insulting.

[SCMunnerlyn1]

If you go by those rating Cam is a better pocket QB than Clausen. He's only going to scramble, if you make him scramble. Cam's stats beat Clausens in every passing category (Throw power, throw accuracy, Short ball and deep ball) only categories that Clausen beats him in is Play action and medium ball by two points.

Oh my bad I forgot to say i'll be trading clausen also :p

My QB will be from the AFL . He plays for philadelphia right now .. Syvelle Newton. I'll be creating him to be basically what Dennis Dixon for Pit is. probably about 78-79 overall and will go from there and build through the draft with my first backup QB as Stephen Garcia from the gamecocks.

I'm a running team guy , all my passes are screens , slants and the occasional deep bomb or playaction version of the mentioned passes.

[CRA]

Well, let's be fair, you've always been a pretty stellar Clausen hater. I wouldn't trade either but that's just me.

this about playing a video game.....if Clausen was the future here AND had the better ratings in terms of video game performance. Why would I trade Clausen? I wouldn't.

I

[Jrock88]

we got shafted again.... can't say I'm surprised. They give Godfrey an 84 but Stewy an 81? Jesus. Who comes up with these ratings?