Comments on Cam from Giants

[CRA]

the biggest problem is Jimmy and CaMMy were o-fer when it came down to 3rd down conversions. That will lead to loses in the regular season. They both need to work on that.

When you evaluate Cam's play.....what you should do is acknowledge on 2 separate occasions on 3rd down he hit WRs with great passes that they both dropped.......

So it aint like Cam didn't do his part every time.....you can't fault a QB for others not doing ther job when it comes to evaluating the QBs role.In addition, I think Cam had 6 throws that went for 1st downs.

[TANTRIC-NINJA]

he's always been a passer first... you can really tell who doesn't understand football when they make drastic claims based on what they thought they saw last year..

..or what they didn't see.

i'm not sure how many people have watched Newton outside of the National Championship game where the whole offense was off rhythm because of the long layoff and the month of defensive preperation.

His accuracy was awful in that game and not indicative to how Cam played all year where he was a percise and deadly passer...and yes because he was a run threat..(for the guys who have argue why Cam completed a high percentage of his passes as if it was bad.)

[Captain Obvious]

When you evaluate Cam's play.....what you should do is acknowledge on 2 separate occasions on 3rd down he hit WRs with great passes that they both dropped.......

So it aint like Cam didn't do his part every time.....you can't fault a QB for others not doing ther job when it comes to evaluating the QBs role.In addition, I think Cam had 6 throws that went for 1st downs.

coulda woulda shoulda BUT he didn't. thats reality. not some alternate cam universe.

[CRA]

coulda woulda shoulda BUT he didn't. thats reality. not some alternate cam universe.

True.....but there is a difference between just evaluating QB play vs. team performance. Cam as far as the throws he made was better than you implied...bc you are allowing what others did discount some of the good that should of been taken from that game.

For example.....Cam made a lot of better throws than his first one that went for 10 yards......and some of those were incompletions.