A qb poll ....

[PantherBrew]

Lol, Saint J made this same thread a couple days ago.

He was blasted, but he has earned it. He's a Saints fan and not coincidentally a douche.

[C47]

You start Clausen, anyone who wouldn't is an idiot. I don't care if you have Peyton Manning on the roster if you have a QB who is performing at that high of a level (120+ passer rating) then you have to ride them to the promised land. Especially when said QB is only 23 years old. As for trading Cam if Clausen were to perform at that high of a level throughout a season and hypothetically a team was willing to give up an early to mid first round pick and a impact player or more picks then you pull the trigger in a heartbeat....

[theyhateme45]

I like the idea of keeping both of them; how can you go wrong with two good, YOUNG, QB's on your team?

Not to mention, they each bring something different to the table. Cam with his legs brings a whole different dimension and using both guys would keep defenses on their toes.

Because if one is playing like Johnny U. Then the other is only sitting on the bench. Instead of having a bench player that player could be traded so that we get a starter(s) who will contribute on the field making the team much better and stronger for a SB run.

[Jpjr]

How about this...

Jimmy is getting the start vs the Giants... he lights it up and on Monday is headed to the WCO Redskins for value. Panthers pick up another CB or DT, Anderson starts the season. Everybody happy.

[C47]

How about this...

Jimmy is getting the start vs the Giants... he lights it up and on Monday is headed to the WCO Redskins for value. Panthers pick up another CB or DT, Anderson starts the season. Everybody happy.

Who do the Skins have at CB or DT of value...

Edit only guy I see is DeAngelo Hall at CB and not only is he overrated but I don't think Hall and Smitty on the same team is a great idea....they REALLY don't like each other....

[HPPantherzfan]

Because if one is playing like Johnny U. Then the other is only sitting on the bench. Instead of having a bench player that player could be traded so that we get a starter(s) who will contribute on the field making the team much better and stronger for a SB run.

And what happens if he gets hurt? Or comes out the next season and plays like Matt Moore did? Trading him you have nothing, keeping him you have a good young replacement

[C47]

And what happens if he gets hurt? Or comes out the next season and plays like Matt Moore did? Trading him you have nothing, keeping him you have a good young replacement

And what happens if Cam Newton never reaches the level that this board (for the most part) thinks he will. Not saying I think he's going to be a bust but if you're playing what if you have to play all sides...

[HPPantherzfan]

And what happens if Cam Newton never reaches the level that this board (for the most part) thinks he will. Not saying I think he's going to be a bust but if you're playing what if you have to play all sides...

HMMM, I don't think you can say that around here but good point

[Gipetto]

ryan leaf looked good in practice

[C47]

HMMM, I don't think you can say that around here but good point

Meh, I'll take my chances...I like to ruffle feathers. And fwiw until he was drafted I hated Jimmy Clausen (being a USC fan) so just wanted to get that out there before I got called a JCJS...

[SOJA]

You go with the QB that is most likely to win you a Super Bowl....which should be your only goal

This

[Toundra]

For me : Use Cam as a situational QB

Like a No huddle offense.

[C47]

For me : Use Cam as a situational QB

Like a No huddle offense.

So you would rather keep a guy to play 10 or fewer plays a game then trade him and get the best CB, DT or WR in the draft next year??

[PantherBrew]

Before we crown either of these QB's lets just see how they play in preseason.