Is wes welker > smitty

[frash.exe]

Lol "even though they're both wide receivers, you can't compare them"

Just because they play different styles doesn't mean we can't rationally conclude who is better

[Guest Spot On Dtan]

Right now?

Maybe (Probably not).

All time?

Don't make me laugh.

[coxc63]

Oh I forgot to mention the dude said in no way he is a bandwagoner, yet he was a red sox fan switched to yankees fan then back to red sox. I would never switch from a panthers fan to any of my division rivals.

As soon as he said that I laughed and told him his arguement lost all credibility that he attempted to prove. I played some madden logged off chat and past out drunk great night lol.

[Guest Jacob3-89]

[Guest Spot On Dtan]

Oh I forgot to mention the dude said in no way he is a bandwagoner, yet he was a red sox fan switched to yankees fan then back to red sox. I would never switch from a panthers fan to any of my division rivals.

As soon as he said that I laughed and told him his arguement lost all credibility that he attempted to prove. I played some madden logged off chat and past out drunk great night lol.

**** him

Go Braves.

[HeatCheck]

Smitty to me is the better all around receiver and I don't think it's that hard of a decision.

Not saying Welker is not good but the Patriots offense is absolutely perfect for Welker. Let me put it this way, if Welker and Smith changed roles/teams, Welker wouldn't look as impressive. I've stated this before but I watch the Patriots more than any other team, besides the Panthers, obviously.

[Jrock88]

Welker is a product of the system. It'd take a Patriots homer to even compare the two.

[SPANKY]

Smitty>Welker all day.

[OneBadassCat]

If Smitty played for NE he would totally embarrass Welker.

[sguil1]

Welker definately better right now. Smith was much better at the peak of his career.

[bleys]

I would take Smitty 10 times out of 10 over Welker..

[Mr Mojo Risin]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1mm6_be70p8&feature=related

show him this and see what he has to say after that

[Guest Spot On Dtan]

Why is this even being discussed.

Brady made Welker.

Smith made an entire franchise

[Panthers128]

We can only judge players on their game day performances. Lately Welker is the better player. Taking entire careers into account and I'd probably go with Smith.