Is wes welker > smitty

[coxc63]

Pound for pound Welker can't really hold Smitty's jock. He's just so much more dynamic than Welker is.

LOL, I stated welker can't sniff smittys jock, he said welker gobbles smiths jock and leaves smith behind asking for more.

[PantherFan52]

The only reason Welker's name can even be spoken in the same sentence as Smitty is because Tom Brady is his QB. Can you Imagine Smitty's numbers if he had Brady throwing him the ball?

[pantherj]

Hmm how do I feel about little Welker?

[nagai]

lol He thinks Welker is top 3? He's a bigger homer than I thought. I gotta say, I'm a lil dissapointed in you. There will always be idiots in the world, you don't need to listen to all the BS.

[Zod]

If Smitty played with Tom Brady he would still be the most dominant WR in the league by far.

Just sayin..

[C47]

This is a retarded statement on so many levels. Smitty is 10 times the receiver Welker is. Welker has one of the greatest QB's of all time throwing him the ball and has a simple role in a loaded offense. Welker is asked to do one thing, go over the middle and make a tough catch. There's a reason that Welker was doing jack poo with the Dolphins and then he blows up with the Pats, because of his role in the offense. If Smitty was on the Pats playing the Welker role he probably would be averaging 120-130 catches every season he was there....

Obvious Pats homer is obvious....

[C47]

welker has produced more than 89 lately so i could see why they think he is better. plus they dont get to watch him do all they little things he does, just like we dont see all of patriots games

You obviously don't watch the NFL on CBS then. They show about 7-8 Patriot games a year on average. I say watching half of their games is a good judge for what the guy can and can't do. Welker is spectacular at one thing....route running. He doesn't have elite speed or hands nor does he have the shiftiness or the ability to break tackles that Smitty does. He runs crisp routes and past the sticks and racks up catches on match ups against LBers. That isn't an elite receiver. Don't get me wrong Welker is GREAT at what he is asked to do but to say he is better then Steve Smith or that Revis is afraid to match up with him is comical and borderline insane. Come talk to me when Welker can take over games without an elite QB throwing him the ball like Smitty, Andre, Calvin, Fitz or any of the elite receivers in the game....

[panther4life]

Belichick offense>John Fox offense

[JoCoLoco]

Smith is the better receiver.

They use Welker better than we use Smith.

[j2sgam]

Welker is 5'9" and stays there.. Smitty is 5'9" and plays 6'10"... Wes is very good at what he does, Smitty is a great receiver...

[C47]

Smith is the better receiver.

They use Welker better than we use Smith.

They use Welker better then Fox and Davidson use Smith. Hopefully Smith gets involved in the offense in more ways then just go out to the X or Z spot and run your route....

[panthers55]

I agree with those folks who say that honestly it is hard to make comparisons between receivers in a pass first offense with a future hall of famer quarterback versus a receiver who has had little help being constantly double teamed on a run first team that has has not had a QB with a great season since 2005. Watch how much better Ocho is in New England's offense this year.

[GritsRgreat]

I freaking love Wes Welker!

I'm talking man crush

[CRA]

If you asked Smitty to go into the NE offense and do what Welker does....I think Smith could be comparable. Welker is a slot machine though. That is his niche.

Welker could do not do what Smith has been asked to over the course of his career.....as a #1