8/4 Updates

[Lout]

Yea, that comment comes from blind hatred. Or he is trolling.

[Kettle]

Y'all CRAZY!! Jerry Rice is old now!

[rayzor]

Trust me; Hurney will never look like a genius with the AE trade. AE could turn into Jerry fuging Rice and Hurney still gave up way too much to draft him.

a 2nd round pick for a legit #2 WR and punt returner? sorry, that seems like a solid move.

not saying that he is legit, yet. but if he becomes one, how could that not seem like a good move?

[PantherBrew]

a 2nd round pick for a legit #2 WR and punt returner? sorry, that seems like a solid move.

not saying that he is legit, yet. but if he becomes one, how could that not seem like a good move?

Some people just wont ever admit they were wrong about something.

I'm not saying he is the man yet, I am still cautiously optimistic that he is going to be a very good, solid player.

I have never wavered on my belief that he was going to work hard until he became a good player, and the special athleticism that he had.

[Ricky Spanish]

the armanti trade will forever be a bad trade because we still could have gotten him in the 4th or 5th round.

could have used that second rounder this past year to get more help on the D-line or secondary.

[pantherfan49]

So are you saying that a 2nd would be too much to give up for Jerry Rice? Your hatred for AE and Hurney runs deeeeeep.

I hate the trade for AE. I would have fired Hurney for it. I don't hate AE, though I do get tired off all of his nut huggers talking about him like he is some great physical specimen.

And I never said that I wouldn't trade a 2nd round pick for Jerry Rice. That wasn't the trade that Hurney made. Hurney traded a 2nd round pick in a year in which we all knew the Panthers would at best be 8-8 and therefore picking in the first half of the draft for a player that was going to be drafted in the 4th round. That's a bad trade. MH you are smart enough to figure that out. Some of the other posters, not so much.

[carolinarolls]

the armanti trade will forever be a bad trade because we still could have gotten him in the 4th or 5th round.

I swag you for throwing the biggest pile of shi+ against the wall yet today.

[PantherBrew]

the armanti trade will forever be a bad trade because we still could have gotten him in the 4th or 5th round.

could have used that second rounder this past year to get more help on the D-line or secondary.

You dont KNOW that.

And Darin Gannt, who is a self-proclaimed app homer, said there was 0% chance that he would have lasted because there were many other teams interested.

You can't say it is a bad trade no matter what because you can't guarantee he would have been there, and what if he turns into the next Smitty? 2nd rounder too much for Smitty?

[Ruff]

I hate the trade for AE. I would have fired Hurney for it. I don't hate AE, though I do get tired off all of his nut huggers talking about him like he is some great physical specimen.

You're a Western alumni, aren't you?

Or is it Michigan?

[PhillyB]

the armanti trade will forever be a bad trade because we still could have gotten him in the 4th or 5th round.

could have used that second rounder this past year to get more help on the D-line or secondary.

not one person on this board knows if we actually COULD have gotten him in the 4th or 5th. his projection to go then doesn't mean he actually would have. thirty-one other general managers could've picked him before then because they had the same idea as hurney.

easy to second-guess someone, hard to actually be in their shoes. if armanti does turn out to be a bust, then crucify him, but if he's successful let's not sit back and nitpick how we got there.

[Ruff]

So, into today's update thread, instead of arguing about Jimmy/Cam/Matt Moore, we argue about Marty Hurney/Armanti Edwards/Jerry Rice?

Awesome.

[pantherfan49]

You're a Western alumni, aren't you?

Or is it Michigan?

I am too stupid for college, even colleges for retards like App State and Western

[PantherBrew]

I am too stupid for college, even colleges for retards like App State and Western

Obvious statement is obvious.

[Raleighcat83]

For everybody saying we could have got AE in the 4th or 5th round, how do you know? Because your Street & Smith Draft Preview magazine told you so? Not saying that Hurney has perfect information about how high he has to move up to get a particular player, but I'm sure his information is just as good as ours, probably better. If AE contributes, it's a good pick.