Keeper League Dilemma

[X-Clown]

I am in year 2 of a keeper league. I was hoping not to make this post TLDR, but I think in order to make an informed recommendation I have to give you all the background on the league.

The story is that you are allowed to keep no more than 2 players, and anyone that you drafted in the first 3 rounds is unavailable to keep. In addition the players that you keep cause you to lose a draft pick 2 rounds higher than he was drafted last year. Undrafted players who ended the season on your roster would cost you a 12th round pick. Looking at the rosters, I can only see 2 QBs who will likely be kept (Vick and Roethlisberger). For running backs, it's likely that Arian Foster, D. McFadden, Hillis, Blount and either Bradshaw or Torain are the only major guys kept and for receivers it's looking like Dez Bryant, Vincent Jackson, Ochocinco, and Steve Johnson are sure bets. In other words, there's going to be a fairly talented pool of guys available.

I've already decided that Jammal Charles who I got in the 4th round is a no-brainer for a keeper since I only lose a 2nd rounder to get potentially a top 5 pick. The real dilemma comes in whether I keep Hakeem Nicks who I got in the 5th round (meaning I would lose a 3rd rounder) or Mike Wallace who I got in the 7th round (meaning I would lose a 5th rounder). Nicks is obviously the better player but with the talent pool being as deep as it is, does keeping Wallace and my 3rd rounder make more sense? I really don't have any decent UDFA options on my roster (Josh Freeman, Jacob Tamme, Mike Goodson).