Jay Cutler Vs Matt Moore

[bLACKpANTHER]

both are young.. Matt just finished his 2nd season, Cutler his 3rd..

both have strong arms.. i def give the edge to Cutler though..

both are gunslingers.. arent afraid to try to fit it into the tight window..

obviously Cutler went early 1st round while Matt wasnt even drafted.. and obviously Cutler seems to be a Star in the making while Moore is a ? with upside.. Moore has no where near the experience, but i know some Panther fans out there believe Moore to be the 'Truth' and heir apparent to the QB throne for Carolina..

SO- if we truly have a shot to get Cutler, i think we shud take it, no doubt.. but if we dont, do we all mainly believe Moore is the man to come in after Jake, or is McCown better suited for our offense..

to me Josh and/or Luke McCown (whoever it is) sounds way too much like Chris Weinke..

[Mr. Scot]

SO- if we truly have a shot to get Cutler, i think we shud take it, no doubt.

We don't.

McDaniels was willing to trade Cutler to get Cassel. That's no longer a possibility, and I seriously doubt that McDaniels is dumb enough to trade away a franchise QB without getting one back.

And no, there are no franchise QBs in the draft, and goofy three way scenarios aren't going to happen either

[jramsey4]

Whoever you believe is the better QB, Jay or Matt, I can tell you that neither of them will be starting for the Panthers next year.

[Kurb]

Next thread please compare a 5 year old peewee WR to steve smith

[mantal]

Personally I'd stick with Moore, it's not like we're desperate, the draft next year looks good it it comes to that. But there's a reason why Dallas fans were pissed off when we snatched him off their practice squad. He had a bad pre-season and injury last year, but he did a helluva job the year before as a rookie. I'd say he deserves a chance, though I'm probably in the minority...

[pantherclaw]

How difficult is it for people to read/research, to find out whether or not a player is even on the market? HE ISN'T ON THE MARKET.

I don't care whatever strange logic you use, learn to research before you make a post like this, or learn to shut the heck up.

[Ncstatefan]

Stop

[pantherclaw]

Personally I'd stick with Moore, it's not like we're desperate, the draft next year looks good it it comes to that. But there's a reason why Dallas fans were pissed off when we snatched him off their practice squad. He had a bad pre-season and injury last year, but he did a helluva job the year before as a rookie. I'd say he deserves a chance, though I'm probably in the minority...

Yes, we are in the minority here.

People couldn't sing his praises enough a year ago. Then he rides the pine (just as every QB needs to do) when Jake comes back. We know we have a QB in Moore that can play the game, has the arm, and can lead the team. He's going to get a chance to lead this team before any other QB we bring in. How do I know this, cause the Panthers aren't going to trade for an ELITE QB ~ specially this year. The FO still believes in, and stands behind Jake, regardless of the viewpoint of the fans.

Despite all this, fans will never stop dreaming about an ELITE QB. That's fine, dream away ~ but realize that currently, that is all it will be ~ a dream.

[jramsey4]

Yes, we are in the minority here.

People couldn't sing his praises enough a year ago. Then he rides the pine (just as every QB needs to do) when Jake comes back. We know we have a QB in Moore that can play the game, has the arm, and can lead the team. He's going to get a chance to lead this team before any other QB we bring in. How do I know this, cause the Panthers aren't going to trade for an ELITE QB ~ specially this year. The FO still believes in, and stands behind Jake, regardless of the viewpoint of the fans.

Despite all this, fans will never stop dreaming about an ELITE QB. That's fine, dream away ~ but realize that currently, that is all it will be ~ a dream.

Hey to be fair, I wanted to upgrade at the QB position last year and everyone said that Matt was the Future and Jake the present. We went into last year with a QB coming off major surgery and one that was a Undrafted Rookie the previous year and only played in 4 games (most of which was against 2nd string defenses). I like Moore and think he is a capable back-up but I want to see more competition at the QB position.

[methodtoll]

Why is this even an argument when McDaniels has clearly stated that HE WON'T TRADE CUTLER!

[CatMan72]

We ain't gonna get Cutler unless we have Matt Cassell to trade to the Broncos.... that was the crux of that whole deal.

[HSCBandit07]

Hey to be fair, I wanted to upgrade at the QB position last year and everyone said that Matt was the Future and Jake the present. We went into last year with a QB coming off major surgery and one that was a Undrafted Rookie the previous year and only played in 4 games (most of which was against 2nd string defenses). I like Moore and think he is a capable back-up but I want to see more competition at the QB position.

That is why we brought in McCown isn't it? I'm surprised no one has mentinoed kurt warner as a possibility. Isn't he looking for a new opportunity?

[jramsey4]

That is why we brought in McCown isn't it? I'm surprised no one has mentinoed kurt warner as a possibility. Isn't he looking for a new opportunity?

Well I would have but he wants a $14 mill contract when we have virtually no cap room.

[pantherclaw]

Hey to be fair, I wanted to upgrade at the QB position last year and everyone said that Matt was the Future and Jake the present. We went into last year with a QB coming off major surgery and one that was a Undrafted Rookie the previous year and only played in 4 games (most of which was against 2nd string defenses). I like Moore and think he is a capable back-up but I want to see more competition at the QB position.

So now you are claiming that Moore played against mostly 2nd string defenses in the most important month to win in the NFL? Please, take your weak ass argument elsewhere please.

That being said, there is more competition AT QB now than we've ever had. No, we don't have an elite QB, but we're not going to trade for one. Any drafted QB is going to be battling for the last QB position, possibly the 2nd QB position if they show enough, but not the first.