Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Choose 1 Free Agent

davos

By davos,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

bleys Newbie

bleys

Posted
Posted

Floyd would be a better pick up than Rice.

Rice has had one.5 good years how much of that was b/c of Farve.

Honestly with all the young WR talent we have do we need another WR if Smith stays ?

Smith, Gettis, Lafell, AE, Hawaii dude, and a Free Agent ?

Coefield would be my choice easily.

Comes from a great D-Line already.

Membane keeps getting thrown around, but I haven't seen him do anything special.

Best FA out there is Ngata, I would rather have him over anyone, even Aso.

Manning isn't a FA (well he is, but yeah)

My concern with Rice would be that hip.. I know there is nothing to base this on, but if that becomes a recurring problem (or triggers a degenerative response), he's only going to have a few decent years (if injuries don't keep him off the field for most of them)...

I do like that he played with good technique in his one good year.. Favre may have had something to do with it (like throw it up regardless if he's open), but he did show he can make those grabs and position his body well enough to beat a corner.

I'd take Holmes over him in a second though.

why would I want a FA WR if Smitty stays? I don't feel Smitty's career is far from over and worst case scenario he has every bit of talent of Hines Ward, if not more. I think he'll be just fine for a number of years. (people blow me away with speed is his only asset... I mean, really? LOL)

with that said, I want a young #1 receiver in conjunction with Smitty.. Gettis has shown real potential, LaFell didn't look too bad either. "Hawaiian dude" and Edwards could become real threats with the ball in their hand, especially if Hawaiian dude can run some true NFL routes on a consistent basis.

having 6 or 7 years of a young #1 receiver would benefit us greatly so that if Smitty becomes plagued with injuries and our other receivers are just #2 and 3 all their career, we have lost nothing.

I feel with the cap room we potentially may have (assuming this pans out), having a true #1 will provide us with that much more of an edge for our rookie QB who may need all the help he can get... I don't see us losing anything, with everything to gain.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SCMunnerlyn1 Proficient

SCMunnerlyn1

Posted
Posted

The fact rice went to the other USC is my point.

He is fluff at this point. IMO.

Not to mention coming off an injury.

Steve Smith came off an injury from 2004 in 2005 .. Triple Crown ?

Edit for teh kurbs realization: Not saying Rice will triple crown , just that one injury shouldn't send you running for the hills.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kurb Newbie

Kurb

Posted
Posted

Steve Smith came off an injury from 2004 in 2005 .. Triple Crown ?

Yes that is totally what will happen.

I remember where steve was considered a bust pretty much his entire career up to that point as well....

If Rice is reasonably cheap I wouldn't have a huge issue with it.

If he wants real $$$ he can GFTO

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kurb Newbie

Kurb

Posted
Posted

Let me get this straight. You believe there ain't be a bidding war for rice? Or that he won't think he's worth top $?

He's not going to come cheap.

I believe his value is highly over-hyped on this board because he played a South Carolina.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bleys Newbie

bleys

Posted
Posted

agree 100%

Aso is probably the best corner in the league. He would upgrade our already pretty decent secondary here in Carolina very nicely. Asomugha would look even better in Carolina than he did in Oakland because of a better team and MUCH better coaching under Mcdermott and Rivera.

For offense, Holmes is the best WR on the market. He has always reminded me of the way that steve smith plays the game. Has a big play ability, and can stretch the feild, and he isnt afraid to go across the middle either. He would be an important weapon for Cam.

Santonio and smitty on the field together would be fantastic, assuming that Cam has something to bring to the table this year for a passing game. If smith decides to leave this year, which i hope he doesnt, santonio would be a lock for the biggest need on the team.

If free agents from carolina count in this discussion, I think that Deangelo williams would continue to play a major role in our offense as well.

Deangelo has always been a big playmaker, and compliments with Stewart very nicely in a record breaking kind of way. I think it is important to have more than one good RB in this league, especially if we end up with an 18 game season. Plus, we may need to rely heavily on the run game this year to help Cam.

truth.. why anyone would pass that up is beyond me.. hoping our unproven players can live up to that? nah, we can have both... (if our coaches and cap can make it happen)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TruCatzFan Newbie

TruCatzFan

Posted
Posted

First off... Y'all are acting like you didn't see that game with Santanio's "supposed" clutch catch... His right toe NEVER touched... I'm just sayin'. Clearly tucked under his left cleat about an inch off the turf...

Anyways, the obvious FA choice is Aso... But NJ panther already pretty much said to fogetaboutit... So that's over. We need a Shutdown Corner for this division to shut down these "elite" QB's.

Definitely need a big time DT or two...

I would love to see Chris Harris back, but that prolly won't happen. He was a BEAST though.

For once... I Definitively have the utmost faith in our franchise to get the missing pieces to the puzzle. That within itself is a huge step forward.

Let the chips fall where they may... It won't matter. We are playoff bound either way!

GO Motherfuggin PANTHERS!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TruCatzFan Newbie

TruCatzFan

Posted
Posted

our options right now are 10X better than Chris Harris.. I appreciate what he did at first, but I feel we upgraded...

True statement... His coverage skills were suspect as hell, but that dude layed the wood!!! Plus he still keeps up with this team and is constantly talking good bout our D.

No doubt we've upgraded. Depth wouldn't hurt though ;-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...