Better Panthers receiver: Smitty or Moose?

[Lumps]

Ah yes comparing the Panthers two good/great WRs in 16 years of existence. Has to be Smitty.

Have we even had another decent receiver that lasted more than a year? I can't even remember.

EDIT: I guess Prohel/Keshawn sort of count but they were proven already and KJ kind of sucked.

[Fiz]

Ah yes comparing the Panthers two good/great WRs in 16 years of existence. Has to be Smitty.

Have we even had another decent receiver that lasted more than a year? I can't even remember.

Ricky Proehl did good things.

Mark Carrier had a few moments.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Smith could do what Moose could do. But it couldn't work the other way around.

I don't know if that's true. Smitty never had 16 touchdowns (red zone threat) and you would be hard pressed to find many better run blockers ever at the position.

They are two completely different players with their own strengths.

[Squirrel]

Big stat.

Moose improved other receivers.

Smitty destroyed them.

[Wither]

Smith almost killed two team mates

Really?

I like them both, though.

[Fiz]

also moose had the 2nd funniest united way commercial ever.

"This...is Muhsin Muhammad. The greatest Wide Receiver in the history of the NFL."

/moose turns and winks

[KillerKat]

Would Smith have become the receiver he was without Moose?

[The Saltman]

Would Smith have become the receiver he was without Moose?

Valid Point

[panthers55]

Most athletic receiver- Smitty

Most willing to leave it on the field- Smitty

Makes those around him better- Moose

Mentor and teammate- Moose

Both have their upsides and downsides.

[DaCityKats]

good question, but i have to go with smitty. we both suffer from little man syndrome.

[KillerKat]

good question, but i have to go with smitty. we both suffer from little man syndrome.

tmi

[DaCityKats]

but i also remember Moose going off that one year, wasnt that the 49ers he torched?

[DaCityKats]

tmi

lmao speaking about being 5'10 160 pounds.

[frash.exe]

smith is the last triple crown winning receiver