Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Better Panthers receiver: Smitty or Moose?


Fiz

Recommended Posts

Oh poo. In this corner, Steve Smith!

135 Games, 8884 yards, 620 receptions, 14.3 YPC, 60 Total TDs (returns), 4 time Pro Bowler, 2 Times all Pro

Marquee Moment

sptscaro_t440.jpg?9e2a24ba44807f8f9b96aad7c4082bf6ded075dc

Best Season: 103 receptions, 1563 yards, 13 Total TDs, 15+ ypc

In the other Corner, Muhsin Muhammad!

Carolina stats only

155 games, 696 receptions, 9255 yards, 13.3 ypc, 50 TDs, 2 Time Pro Bowler, 1 time all pro,

Marquee Moment

2940263.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=77BFBA49EF878921F7C3FC3F69D929FDDEA7109EC51E9DC644DBFDD3EF5B749D804AF83FA159F5EDE30A760B0D811297

best season: 93 receptions, 1405 yards, 15ypc, 16 TDs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

also don't forget Moose has only been in trouble once, when he was found with weed and a gun in his car. No one even remembers that.

Smith almost killed two team mates and got busted for pills.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Take them both in their prime and look at them. Who are you going to take?

Smith is much faster, more explosive, more elusive, and just as clutch as Moose ever was.

Smith could do what Moose could do. But it couldn't work the other way around.

Moose was great but Smith makes you say "Oh my god".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Love them both.

Moose was my favorite Panther when I started liking them a lot.

After he left, Smitty became my favorite.

When Moose came back I was ecstatic. I love em both.

Gotta go Smitty though. He'd of been considered one of the greatest of all time had he been with a great QB throughout his entire career. He's one of the most talented football players I've ever seen, period.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

also don't forget Moose has only been in trouble once, when he was found with weed and a gun in his car. No one even remembers that.

Smith almost killed two team mates and got busted for pills.

almost killed? :lol:

Marijuana>pills in a court of law.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

almost killed? :lol:

Marijuana>pills in a court of law.

He easily could have killed Anthony Bright.

Ken Lucas was only saved by all his previous rhinoplasty which is what smith was aiming for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Oh he would absolutely flourish. It’s the panthers way. It’s no different with coaches. Sometimes they reach their expiration date, go somewhere else, and find new success.  Similarly to Burns, how long to wait for the light to finally turn on?  Market forces will demand a salary that the panthers can not responsibly match. Sliding him to guard will fit his skill set better, but he has played LT for 3 years. He will receive offers from other teams wanting to pay him LT money.  At guard, he won’t start with what they have paid Hunt and Lewis. Center then?? Dunno. Maybe? He will become a backup by default once they draft their stud LT. I doubt Dan just stands pat. That’s not his MO.  So where does this put him? Can you match what other teams will offer for a backup LT/guard? Do you dish out franchise LT $ on a guy who still needs significant improvement in pass protection. This team will be DOA in the playoffs with the very first team who has a formidable speed rusher. What if he has hit his ceiling in pass protection already and they sign him long term? It’s a big gamble either way. 
    • We're in a great position to see just how big of a misstep it would be, having made so many ourselves
    • I didn't say I would have done it. I was just saying that I can see why some in the FO considered it. Everything was done to give Bryce weapons. Solidify the interior line thru FA. Get XL at WR in round 1 and then get the most talented RB in round 2. Take a TE in round 4, etc They were probably "assuming" he'd make a complete recovery during the 2024 season. I'm a skeptical person. I wouldn't have assumed he'd be ok in 2024. I personally would have taken another position in the 2nd for that very reason. But, if I were "influenced" to take him I would've argued to keep him off the field, especially seeing how things were going for us record wise. Conventional Wisdom says most backs don't get back to normal until two years after the ACL surgery. He was injured in Fall 2023. Having him suit up in 2025 would have been almost 2 years since the original injury. You have him for 3 year on low contract. If he balls out, you resign him for a couple of more years b/c he'd only have 3 years of tread on the tires. If he's ok but not great you let him walk. 
×
×
  • Create New...