Better Panthers receiver: Smitty or Moose?

[Fiz]

Oh poo. In this corner, Steve Smith!

135 Games, 8884 yards, 620 receptions, 14.3 YPC, 60 Total TDs (returns), 4 time Pro Bowler, 2 Times all Pro

Marquee Moment

Best Season: 103 receptions, 1563 yards, 13 Total TDs, 15+ ypc

In the other Corner, Muhsin Muhammad!

Carolina stats only

155 games, 696 receptions, 9255 yards, 13.3 ypc, 50 TDs, 2 Time Pro Bowler, 1 time all pro,

Marquee Moment

best season: 93 receptions, 1405 yards, 15ypc, 16 TDs

[The Saltman]

Less games, only 76 less receptions, More TDs, better yards after the catch, More Pro Bowl Appearances.

When was the last time a Defensive coordinator really schemed for Moose? 1 year.

Steve smith all the way baby!!

[OneBadassCat]

Smith is the best of all time

[KSpan]

Tough call, but I'd say Smitty due to extra explosiveness and YAC ability.

[Fiz]

2 years, Saltman.

If you'd been a Panthers fan in 2000 you'd remember that.

[The Saltman]

lol ouch

[Fiz]

also don't forget Moose has only been in trouble once, when he was found with weed and a gun in his car. No one even remembers that.

Smith almost killed two team mates and got busted for pills.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

I demand Mark Carrier and Patrick Jeffers receive consideration to give us more stuff to talk about during this dead period.

[OneBadassCat]

Take them both in their prime and look at them. Who are you going to take?

Smith is much faster, more explosive, more elusive, and just as clutch as Moose ever was.

Smith could do what Moose could do. But it couldn't work the other way around.

Moose was great but Smith makes you say "Oh my god".

[Cat'sGrowl]

Love them both.

Moose was my favorite Panther when I started liking them a lot.

After he left, Smitty became my favorite.

When Moose came back I was ecstatic. I love em both.

Gotta go Smitty though. He'd of been considered one of the greatest of all time had he been with a great QB throughout his entire career. He's one of the most talented football players I've ever seen, period.

[The Saltman]

also don't forget Moose has only been in trouble once, when he was found with weed and a gun in his car. No one even remembers that.

Smith almost killed two team mates and got busted for pills.

almost killed? :lol:

Marijuana>pills in a court of law.

[Fiz]

almost killed? :lol:

Marijuana>pills in a court of law.

He easily could have killed Anthony Bright.

Ken Lucas was only saved by all his previous rhinoplasty which is what smith was aiming for.

[The Saltman]

we could argue about this for forever. I love them both and wish we had them both at their prime and could do it all over again this year.

Oh and I hate you.

[OneBadassCat]

Desean Jackson wishes he could be Steve Smith.

Nooblet don't have swag.