Which Panthers rookie will have the best season?

[Razzy]

I asked this question last year and along with a lot of others I was very wrong.

http://www.carolinahuddle.com/forum/carolina-panthers/35823-which-rookie-will-have-the-best-season.html

So I ask again.

I'll go with Fua at DT. Cam is the dark horse, but it's ultimately a game of playing time.

[Squirrel]

Went with Hogan. He will learn the quickest and see the most action behind Cam. Cam will take some time to learn but Hogan will have the better season overall.

[The Other Colbert]

Went with Hogan. He will learn the quickest and see the most action behind Cam. Cam will take some time to learn but Hogan will have the better season overall.

yeah it would have nothing to do with you being a wvu fan:rolleyes:

haha i kid

[Catalyst]

If he plays, Cam. Otherwise, Pilares.

[Jackofalltrades]

Hogan, but McClain will benefit from having CJ drawing most of the attention.

[Carolina Crazy V2]

I picked Cam, but I meant to click McClain.

[Raskle]

I went arbitrarily with Fua.. but I have the feeling we could have scored some excellent DTs this year. No scientific proof, just a flat-out hunch. :)

[Swarly]

I agree with Hogan. With Marshall leaving he'll be the guy to fill that void than Captain. I've heard from a lot of people that we got an absolute steal if he stays healthy.

and dudes, I'm rooting for Newton, but you have to realize that rookie seasons like Ryan's/Bradford's/etc are rare. Most of the time a rookie QB will be terrible but show a lot of potential(ie actually score points and make big plays). Newton will probably have some highlight reel plays but in the end will have a rather below average year.

Freeman was flat out terrible in his first season, but showed flashes of being really f'in good. I see Newtons season being similar to that.

[markbm62]

McClain: have a feeling this young man is going to be good.

[Lumps]

lol I had to bump the last one everyone saying Armanti, just shows....

I say McClain but it is more of a hope more than a prediction.

[Jangler]

which season?

[Millions]

Swag Newton he'll find ways to make plays whether that be with his legs or arm to be productive as a rookie ala Vince Young imo.

[SirPanther]

Cam's got that swag so that's why I voted for him.

:cam:

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Cam, but I could see Hogan killing it too. He's got mad instincts.

And LOL at last years. I am one of the genius few who didn't say Armanti or Jimmy.

Robert McClain for the win.