What QB would you like to have backup Cam Newton?

[hepcat]

Now that Cam Newton has arrived and has essentially been crowned the new king in Carolina, what QB would you most prefer to backup Cam as he goes through "the process"?

I'm voting Matt Moore - at least we know he's capable of winning a few games, and he's not pickles.

[ncmonzta]

Now that Cam Newton has arrived and has essentially been crowned the new king in Carolina, what QB would you most prefer to backup Cam as he goes through "the process"?

McNabb if he can sit on the bench without whining

[C47]

I hope Cam is the backup learning from a vet like McNabb or Hasselbeck...

[hepcat]

McNabb if he can sit on the bench without whining

Would be nice...similar style of QB. But does McNabb really want to sit on the bench, and for how much $$$??? Is he even leaving Washington? They had a shot at Gabbert and traded the pick.

[Cat'sGrowl]

I'd be giddy if we landed Hasselbeck. Doubt it though.

[rico6]

It would be a dream come true to land a "good" veteran QB while Cam can sit and learn.

[Darth Biscuit]

Other... a vet from somewhere...

Is Chris Weinke available? :D

[ncmonzta]

Would be nice...similar style of QB. But does McNabb really want to sit on the bench, and for how much $$$??? Is he even leaving Washington? They had a shot at Gabbert and traded the pick.

I doubt he'd want to sit. I think Cam wouldnt mind sitting and learning from him. McNabb is good to miss at least 5 games a season anyway. I think the Redskins will look at another free agent QB or draft one today. McNabb wont cost much if he's released no one will pay top dollar for him to play.

[blackcatgrowl]

Tough question.

Consider the factors:

1. New Coach - Rivera must show improvement immediately. He really needs at least a 6-10 or 7-9 season, minimum, to solidify his reputation. Anything less, and he risks criticism and doubt, something which can be detrimental to his leadership.

2. Our schedule - Worst in the league... even 6-10 is a daunting task which will require our current talent to step up, and any FA QB to be consistent and competent.

3. Our division - Toughest in the league. Atlanta is fairly young. Tampa is very young. New Orleans is a very well managed team and is already making smart moves to keep going strong. We need some awesome talent starting immediately to dent these guys.

4. Our current QBs - Moore is a competent backup. He could even been a decent temporary QB. Not sure what he offers as a mentor however. Clausen is not starting material. Pike is a 3rd stringer. Not looking great for options here.

5. Who's available? - One of the considerations going into the draft was WHO would we take in Free Agency if we didn't take Newton. The answer was pretty bleak. Still is. McNabb is a name getting thrown around... but honestly... there's something wrong with McNabb. He's got a shakey work ethic (not bad, just a little too quick to blame others for his failings). I don't trust him to properly mentor Newton. Who else does that leave? Palmer? Volek?

6. The price of a Free Agent - Money is not an unlimited resource for our team. We've got several Free Agents we have to resign already on our team. Even without a salary cap, it's going to be tough paying a FA QB who's good enough to deal with points 1, 2 and 3 above.

I'd say our best bet right now is to let our current stable compete in camp and preseason and start the best option. UNLESS... there is a QB who suddenly becomes available who we can afford that is a no-brainer pickup.

[blackcatgrowl]

McNabb if he can sit on the bench without whining

Yeah, see.... that's what I'm worried about with McNabb. I say we steer clear.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Moore has nothing to offer Newton. Let Matty go somewhere else and try and become a starter. We need a vet to help Cam. Jimmy getting pushed to third string is going to be crazy though.

[Kettle]

specify is better than all those guys. i'd choose him.

[rayzor]

any QB with more than 5 years starting experience.

i want someone that has a clue whats going on out there on the field.

[top dawg]

Any place that McNabb goes, he has to realize that he's not the future anymore. Perhaps he is ready to accept this realization. I'd test the waters. Nothing says that Newton has to play this year (except injury). Rivera already said, in so many words, that he is not going to throw Cam to the wolves.