Last time 16th ranked player went #1??

[Floppin]

Since when does the player with the highest passer rating in NCAA history NOT warrant the number 1 pick for a team that badly needs a quarterback and a franchise player?

Where in the hell do you get that stat from? Newton does not hold the NCAA record, he wasn't even number 1 THIS YEAR, Kellen Moore was.

[xcarnx]

Tom Brady was a fluke that plays for an organization that is known for cheating. Its always easier to win if you cheat. For the comment about worst offense not taking a QB. Doesnt mattet if the Panthers sign Peyton M. They would still suck because ownership doesnt want to spend money.

[monstercat]

I wonder where they had Duke Robinson rated?

[blackcatgrowl]

The fact that Gabbert is #5 takes away any credibility that list was supposed to have:rofl:

This.

[AnalyzeThIs#28]

I want a QB that can throw the ball better than he can run with the ball, we have amazing RBs already. Just doesn't make any sense to draft a QB that isn't accurate with throwing the ball.

[panfan32]

I say we trade down give our Current QB staff a chance this year. If it does not work out Luck will get drafted by us next year.

[Jerry]

Makes no sense to take this guy,loaded with baggage

that is inaccurate and runs. In the NFL when a QB runs

it is the signal for the defense to take him out of the game.

When he makes just one inaccurate throw it'll be a pick.

I agree he has a big potential, a big potential to BUST.

Sailor Jerry

[eViL jEsTeR]

Since when do those ranking mean anything? Wasn't JaMarcus Russell the number 1 rated prospect?

true, but that was the dumb ass raiders and look how that turned out.