QB Power Rankings

[Leeroy Jenkins PhD]

Their team has proven they can win without him. He has literally just gone along for the ride.

Don't get me wrong, he's very good. But he's nowhere near the level of Manning, Brady, Brees, Rodgers, and Rivers

Now, I don't think very highly of Big Ben, but I can tell you this, I think the Panthers, position by position are very talented. Just goes to show you that not having a QB is pretty detrimental

[TheRealDeal]

Now, I don't think very highly of Big Ben, but I can tell you this, I think the Panthers, position by position are very talented. Just goes to show you that not having a QB is pretty detrimental

We didn't have near the defense, near the WRs, near the coaches that they did.

Invalid comparison

[Ricky Spanish]

rapelisberger sucked in 2 of the 3 super bowls he played in, and hasn't been anything spectacular throughout the seasons.

he is good, probably very good, but not elite.

[Peppers90 NC]

Their team has proven they can win without him. He has literally just gone along for the ride.

Don't get me wrong, he's very good. But he's nowhere near the level of Manning, Brady, Brees, Rodgers, and Rivers

Except maybe when his team rode him in that last 2 minute drive against the Cards(yea I know Holmes had a crazy catch). I put him top 5 but I understand how it's debatable. I know many guys that dont like him for whatever reason. He is somewhat of a loose cannon, but I like his guts, leadership, throwing ability, mobility and toughness.

Pitt would still be good without him maybe, but they wouldn't be great.

[The Saltman]

lol there is no way in hell they would have been as good or won as many superbowls if they didnt have him.

Good try though.

[4Corners]

Romo should be off the list.

[The Saltman]

You guys really think Charlie Batch would be in the superbowl? :lol:

[Peppers90 NC]

You guys really think Charlie Batch would be in the superbowl? :lol:

No of course not, nor Dennis Dixon or Leftwich. He is very hateable guy, and that skews peoples opinion.

[Raskle]

You guys really think Charlie Batch would be in the superbowl? :lol:

No, but Dilfer was..... you guys are talking about Trent, right?

[James Ellis]

Manning and Brady are All-Time greats. Rodgers could eventually be. I don't think Brees will get to that level, but he's definitely one of the best QBs of the last decade.

Everyone else on that list is "pretty good".