Where would you draft them?

[Ricky Spanish]

Matt Ryan, and if freeman shows another year of improvement like last year, he'd be my #1.

I really really like freeman a whole hell of a lot.

[mav1234]

Its hard to say who I would take number 1 considering most of them are early in there careers and without knowing who else is on the draft board with them. Its all fairly circumstantial.

Also how did you come to that list? That is an interesting assortment of quarterbacks.

Where they were drafted, the success they had, why I may think they had that success, and just looking for a decent sample size of names to stick out there.

So am I correct in assuming that only Freeman and Ryan have had any votes for being taken #1 overall?

[C47]

Where they were drafted, the success they had, why I may think they had that success, and just looking for a decent sample size of names to stick out there.

So am I correct in assuming that only Freeman and Ryan have had any votes for being taken #1 overall?

I said Flacco to, I think his interceptions are partly because of having to play the Steelers two and sometimes three times a season....

[mav1234]

I said Flacco to' date=' I think his interceptions are partly to blame for having to play the Steelers two and sometimes three times a season....[/quote']

Haha, there's that. At the same time, the Ravens have been a solid team for a long, long time. He hasn't been able to take the next step yet. I just can't see him being worth the #1 personally.

[Icege]

Who would we take #1 in hindsight (which is always 20/20), or who would we have been sold on the most from scouting reports?

[C47]

Haha, there's that. At the same time, the Ravens have been a solid team for a long, long time. He hasn't been able to take the next step yet. I just can't see him being worth the #1 personally.

I can see the argument that he hasn't taken the next step yet, although it could be argued that neither have Ryan or Freeman. Ryan is one and done in the playoffs and Freeman hasn't gotten there yet. Flacco made it to an AFC title game his rookie season....

[Zithers]

Big Ben by a lot. Not a choker, can sling it, can move in the pocket, etc.

[teeray]

Instead of doing all of them, I would probably take Ryan #1, followed bu Big Ben and Freeman although you could probably make a compelling case for any of these three #1 IMO.

[carpanfan96]

For me (speaking long term here) It be a tough choice between Freeman and Ryan, both are solid big qb's with strong accurate arms and I would definitely take both of them #1 overall.

[Catalyst]

1) Big Ben - 1st overall

2) Freeman - 1st overall

3) Matt Ryan - 1st overall

4) Joe Flacco - top 10-15

5) Stafford - top-10-15

6) Mark Sanchez - 1st round

7) Vince Young - 4th round

8) Alex Smith - 4th round

[mav1234]

Vince Young in the 4th! I like it. :D

[JawnyBlaze]

Freeman or Ryan at #1, Flacco around 5, Stafford around 7 or 8, Big Ben around 15, none of the others in the first. If I had my choice of the lot, it'd be Freeman.

[JawnyBlaze]

Big Ben is definately worth a #1. he is the only one of the bunch that has won a ring. he has two rings because he is a big tall QB who is good at avoiding the takle for just a second in order to let a play develop downfeild.

Big Ben does NOT have two rings because he is a big tall QB who is good at avoiding the tackle. He has two rings because he has an awesome defense and an acceptable offense AROUND him. Once again, how bad does a QB have to be to get passed over for Super Bowl MVP TWICE? And not like Aikman where "oh, he already got it once, let's give it to one of the other guys that deserve some recognition". He just flat out doesn't deserve credit for the Super Bowl wins.

[nagai]

I wouldn't draft the last 2 in the first round. Sanchez and Flacco are funny, one gets great stats in the regular season and sucks during the postseason, the other one sucks during the regular season but lights it up in the playoffs. I'll say both of them will warrant a high-ish 1st round pick, maybe 10th, though I wouldn't be sad if we drafted them 1st overall either. The rest are worth the 1st overall pick.