Which QB would you compare Cam Newton to?

[Peppers90 NC]

Raiders nearly made the playoffs this year.

You're reaching, again. But yea after 4-12, 4-12 and 5-11, last year they were the John Fox Carolina Panthers at 8-8. This after trading for a QB and cutting the bust. Sure... they ALMOST made the playoffs. Remember, we are not in the AFCW.

[Peppers90 NC]

But hey, at least the Raiders ALMOST did it with the guy I compared Cam to.

[Steel Panther]

I hope I'm wrong, I really do, but I have the same feeling about Cam that I had about Vince Young coming out of Texas...great talent, awesome college player, but so-so pro.

IF the Panthers pick him, I hope he proves me wrong! PLEASE, prove me wrong, Newt!

[Eazy-E]

I hope I'm wrong, I really do, but I have the same feeling about Cam that I had about Vince Young coming out of Texas...great talent, awesome college player, but so-so pro.

IF the Panthers pick him, I hope he proves me wrong! PLEASE, prove me wrong, Newt!

Thing that sets Cam apart from Young coming out of College is that Cam is already a much better passer then Young was.

[MWCarolina]

A mixture of different guys. i think he has Freeman's arm and size, but he has a little less speed than Young. i dont think his running is going to be as good as some want or think which means he will have to use that arm of his more.

[Marguide]

I hope I'm wrong, I really do, but I have the same feeling about Cam that I had about Vince Young coming out of Texas...great talent, awesome college player, but so-so pro.

IF the Panthers pick him, I hope he proves me wrong! PLEASE, prove me wrong, Newt!

People talk about Vince Young as a bust. Vince Young would have been one of the most successful young QB's in the league if he had his head screwed on straight.

VY's QB rating last year was like 103. If he wasn't a headcase, a lot of teams would be looking for the next Vince Young.

[Actionman0z]

"Steamin" Willie Beamen

You can't defend this, you're dreamin'. LOL Delhomme would be Quaid. haha