Top 2 WRs in NFL: Roddy White and Brandon Lloyd

[bLACKpANTHER]

Guess who voted them 1 and 2?

Top WRs list

by the way, Smitty didn't make anyones Top 10

[The Saltman]

Smitty wasnt good enough to be in the top ten last year. Clausen or not.

[Swarly]

Smitty wasnt good enough to be in the top ten last year. Clausen or not.

yep

I will say that while Roddy White is good, anyone that doesn't put Andre Johnson/Fitz as #1/#2(order doesn't matter, as far as I'm concerned it's 1a and 1b) probably doesn't watch Texans/Cardinals games.

[wade]

And he has Andre Johnson ranked #6? Huh?

EDIT: And Paul Kuharsky (who?) has Fitz ranked #9. :lol:

[Jackofalltrades]

Fitzgerald and Johnson.

[countryboi]

Smitty wasnt good enough to be in the top ten last year. Clausen or not.

i am calling bullshit on this......there is no way in hell brandon lloyd is more talented than smitty....put smith in that pass happy system and he would lead the league in yards too

[OneBadassCat]

Fitzgerald isn't top 2 without Kurt Warner and Boldin. Johnson still takes #1 imo. Roddy White is a falcon and therefore can't be good.

Smith can't make anyones top 10 without a QB.

[pantherclaw]

Smitty hasn't been top 10 for more than just last season.

[Swarly]

Fitzgerald isn't top 2 without Kurt Warner and Boldin. Johnson still takes #1 imo. Roddy White is a falcon and therefore can't be good.

Smith can't make anyones top 10 without a QB.

Fitzgerald put up 90 receptions, 1,137 yards, and 6 touchdowns with a quarterback situation comparable to ours. He runs the best routes and has the best hands in the NFL.

Andre and Fitz are 1a, 1b.

[The Saltman]

i am calling bullpoo on this......there is no way in hell brandon lloyd is more talented than smitty....put smith in that pass happy system and he would lead the league in yards too

im not saying brandon lloyd is a more talented receiver. Read my posts next time.

[AceMan]

That list doesn't say that...

Edit: NVM, I'm an idiot. So is Pat Y.

[CRA]

Fitzgerald put up 90 receptions, 1,137 yards, and 6 touchdowns with a quarterback situation comparable to ours. He runs the best routes and has the best hands in the NFL.

Andre and Fitz are 1a, 1b.

No he didn't. HUGE difference between Smitty working w/ a bum like Moore and complete slop in Clausen.

Smitty had decent production in 2010 and 2009 with Moore. Very good production actually. Non existant w/ Clausen. Fitz did not have a comparable QB as Clausen.

Best WRs in the NFL are Andre Johnson and Calvin Johnson. Some may have better seasons or get the ball more....but those two imo are the best.

[OneBadassCat]

Fitzgerald put up 90 receptions, 1,137 yards, and 6 touchdowns with a quarterback situation comparable to ours. He runs the best routes and has the best hands in the NFL.

Andre and Fitz are 1a, 1b.

The Cardinals had over 700 more passing yards then us. No experienced WR in the league had to go through what Smith did last year, or even the year before.

Smith hasn't really had much in his favor his whole career here, save the playaction/run game. He doesn't get many of the luxuries the other top 10 WRs do.

[Swarly]

you guys realize who the Cardinals had at QB right? QB rating was a whole 3 points higher than ours(60 QB rating) with ONE more touchdown and two MORE interceptions.

they had Derek Anderson, Max Hall, John Skelton, and some random backup. Andre Johnson had Matt Schaub..