What if you knew.

[PantherBrew]

What if you knew how many pro-bowls the top prospects at their positions were going to have. Since QB is more important position lets give them less.

*I know probowls are not the best measurement of NFL success.

PP7- 4 probowls in 5 years.

Newton- 2 probowls in 5 years.

Gabbert- 2 probowls in 5 years.

Fairley- 3 probowls in 5 years.

Dareus- 3 probowls in 5 years.

Which one would you take?

Why?

How many probowls would it take to alter your choice to someone else?

I know there are soooo many other variables, such as QB's winning % and playoff success, but just humor me.

[TheGreatOne]

The Panthers will draft Cam Newton and he'll make the Pro Bowl after he leads us to the playoffs in his 2nd season. His 3rd season he'll make the Pro Bowl but won't be able to play in it because he'll be leading the Panthers to their 1st Super Bowl Championship! Then he'll make the Pro Bowl for the rest of his career like Peyton Manning.

[PantherBrew]

The Panthers will draft Cam Newton and he'll make the Pro Bowl after he leads us to the playoffs in his 2nd season. His 3rd season he'll make the Pro Bowl but won't be able to play in it because he'll be leading the Panthers to 1st Super Bowl Championship!

Sorry about your genetics.

[csx]

Easy, Newton or Gabbert

Becuase we need a good QB

[RedMage138]

The Panthers will draft Cam Newton and he'll make the Pro Bowl after he leads us to the playoffs in his 2nd season. His 3rd season he'll make the Pro Bowl but won't be able to play in it because he'll be leading the Panthers to 1st Super Bowl Championship! Then he'll make the Pro Bowl for the rest of his career like Peyton Manning.

:smilielol5:

In that scenario, Dareus.

[PantherBrew]

Easy, Newton or Gabbert

Becuase we need a good QB

Vince Young made 2 probowls.

[csx]

Vince Young made 2 probowls.

Ok

[Ricky Spanish]

Easy, Newton or Gabbert

Becuase we need a good QB

this

[Jackofalltrades]

Dareus.

[PantherBrew]

So there is an agreement that a good QB is a probowler in 2 out of 5 seasons?

[PantherBrew]

Im surprised at the lack of PP7 love with 4 probowls.

remember, we can still draft a QB next year.

[Ricky Spanish]

i'd say two pro bowls would make you a good young QB. Don't give me that VY is a good QB argument though, he got defaulted into the pro bowl the other year because a few QBs couldn't go. David Garrard did too.

I guess if they are legitimately voted into the pro bowl then yeah, they are good, but the OP didn't specify this.

[mmmbeans]

i'd be very happy with any of those. Team's got enough holes, don't really care who we draft as long as they develop into a high-level player.

[Ricky Spanish]

i'd be very happy with any of those. Team's got enough holes, don't really care who we draft as long as they develop into a high-level player.

I guess you're right. Beggars can't be choosers after all...